On Growth and Form

Sir D’Arcy Wentworth Thompson — Cambridge University Press (First Edition, 1917)

First Edition (Cambridge, 1917): On Growth and Form, by D’Arcy Wentworth Thompson, Cambridge: at the University Press, 1917 (xv + 793 pp., 17 chapters, 408 figures).
Digital Scriptorium Codex: Synchronized 3-track edition (English · Summary · Notes) with 10 theme-adaptive .euclid-graphic SVG plates curated within the GEOMETOR canon.

“Cum formarum naturalium et corporalium esse non consistat nisi in unione ad materiam, ejusdem agentis esse videtur eas producere cujus est materiam transmutare. Secundo, quia cum hujusmodi formae non excedant virtutem et ordinem et facultatem principiorum agentium in natura, nulla videtur necessitas eorum originem in principia reducere altiora.”

—St. Thomas Aquinas, De Potentia Dei, Q. iii, a. 11 (1917 Epigraph)


Table of Contents

Prefatory Note, Epigraphs & Chapter I: Introductory

“The reasonings about the wonderful and intricate operations of nature are so full of uncertainty, that, as the Wise-man truly observes, hardly do we guess aright at the things that are upon earth, and with labour do we find the things that are before us.” Stephen Hales, Vegetable Staticks (1727), p. 318, 1738.

A. Geometrically Similar Cubes (L = 1, 2, 3) B. Surface S ~ L² vs. Mass V ~ L³ L = 1 S = 6, V = 1 L = 2 S = 24, V = 8 L = 3 S = 54, V = 27 1 2 3 Linear Scale L V ~ L³ (Weight) S ~ L² (Strength) S / V ~ 1/L

Chapter II: On Magnitude

To terms of magnitude, and of direction, must we refer all our conceptions of form. For the form of an object is defined when we know its magnitude, actual or relative, in various directions; and growth involves the same conceptions of magnitude and direction, with this addition, that they are supposed to alter in time. Before we proceed to the consideration of specific form, it will be worth our while to consider, for a little while, certain phenomena of spatial magnitude, or of the extension of a body in the several dimensions of space .

Chapter III: The Rate of Growth

When we study magnitude by itself, apart, that is to say, from the gradual changes to which it may be subject, we are dealing with a something which may be adequately represented by a number, or by means of a line of definite length; it is what mathematicians call a scalar phenomenon. When we introduce the conception of change of magnitude, of magnitude which varies as we pass from one direction to another in space, or from one instant to another in time, our phenomenon becomes capable of representation by means of a line of which we define both the length and the direction; it is (in this particular aspect) what is called a vector phenomenon.

Chapter IV: On the Internal Form and Structure of the Cell

In the early days of the cell-theory, more than seventy years ago, Goodsir was wont to speak of cells as “centres of growth” or “centres of nutrition,” and to consider them as essentially “centres of force.” He looked forward to a time when the forces connected with the cell should be particularly investigated: when, that is to say, minute anatomy should be studied in its dynamical aspect. “When this branch of enquiry,” he says “shall have been opened up, we shall expect to have a science of organic forces, having direct relation to anatomy, the science of organic forms .” And likewise, long afterwards, Giard contemplated a science of morphodynamique,—but still looked upon it as forming so guarded and hidden a “territoire scientifique, que la plupart des naturalistes de nos jours ne le verront que comme Moïse vit la terre promise, seulement de loin et sans pouvoir y entrer .”

Chapter V: The Forms of Cells

Protoplasm, as we have already said, is a fluid or rather a semifluid substance, and we need not pause here to attempt to describe the particular properties of the semifluid, colloid, or jelly-like substances to which it is allied; we should find it no easy matter. Nor need we appeal to precise theoretical definitions of fluidity, lest we come into a debateable land. It is in the most general sense that protoplasm is “fluid.” As Graham said (of colloid matter in general), “its softness partakes of fluidity, and enables the colloid to become a vehicle for liquid diffusion, like water itself .” When we can deal with protoplasm in sufficient quantity we see it flow; particles move freely through it, air-bubbles and liquid droplets shew round or spherical within it; and we shall have much to say about other phenomena manifested by its own surface, which are those especially characteristic of liquids. It may encompass and contain solid bodies, and it may “secrete” within or around itself solid substances; and very often in the complex living organism these solid substances formed by the living protoplasm, like shell or nail or horn or feather, may remain when the protoplasm which formed them is dead and gone; but the protoplasm itself is fluid or semifluid, and accordingly permits of free (though not necessarily rapid) diffusion and easy convection of particles within itself. This simple fact is of elementary importance in connection with form, and with what appear at first sight to be common characteristics or peculiarities of the forms of living things.

Chapter VI: A Note on Adsorption

A very important corollary to, or amplification of the theory of surface tension is to be found in the modern chemico-physical doctrine of Adsorption . In its full statement this subject soon becomes complicated, and involves physical conceptions and mathematical treatment which go beyond our range. But it is necessary for us to take account of the phenomenon, though it be in the most elementary way.

A. Steiner–Fermat 120° Junction X(13) B. Hexagonal Cellular Equilibrium (s = 3/4) A B C 120° P = X(13) Plateau's First Law: three films meet at 120° Minimal perimeter partition (spread s = 3/4)

Chapter VII: The Forms of Tissues, or Cell-Aggregates

We now pass from the consideration of the solitary cell to that of cells in contact with one another,—to what we may call in the first instance “cell-aggregates,”—through which we shall be led ultimately to the study of complex tissues. In this part of our subject, as in the preceding chapters, we shall have to give some consideration to the effects of various forces; but, as in the case of the conformation of the solitary cell, we shall probably find, and we may at least begin by assuming, that the agency of surface tension is especially manifest and important. The effect of this surface tension will chiefly manifest itself in the production of surfaces minimae areae: where, as Plateau was always careful to point out, we must understand by this expression not an absolute, but a relative minimum, an area, that is to say, which approximates to an absolute minimum as nearly as circumstances and the conditions of the case permit.

Chapter IX: On Concretions, Spicules, and Spicular Skeletons

The deposition of inorganic material in the living body, usually in the form of calcium salts or of silica, is a very common and wide-spread phenomenon. It begins in simple ways, by the appearance of small isolated particles, crystalline or non-crystalline, whose form has little relation or sometimes none to the structure of the organism; it culminates in the complex skeletons of the vertebrate animals, in the massive skeletons of the corals, or in the polished, sculptured and mathematically regular molluscan shells. Even among many very simple organisms, such as the Diatoms, the Radiolarians, the Foraminifera, or the Sponges, the skeleton displays extraordinary variety and beauty, whether by reason of the intrinsic form of its elementary constituents or the geometric symmetry with which these are arranged and interconnected.

Chapter X: A Parenthetic Note on Geodetics

We have made use in the last chapter of the mathematical principle of Geodetics (or Geodesics) in order to explain the conformation of a certain class of sponge-spicules; but the principle is of much wider application in morphology, and would seem to deserve attention which it has not yet received.

The Equiangular Spiral of Nautilus: r = a e^(θ cot α), Constant Tangent Angle α P (∠OPT = α ≈ 80°) O Bernoulli's Spira mirabilis: growth at aperture preserves unchanging form (Eadem mutata resurgo)

Chapter XI: The Logarithmic Spiral

The very numerous examples of spiral conformation which we meet with in our studies of organic form are peculiarly adapted to mathematical methods of investigation. But ere we begin to study them, we must take care to define our terms, and we had better also attempt some rough preliminary classification of the objects with which we shall have to deal.

Chapter XII: The Spiral Shells of the Foraminifera

We have already dealt in a few simple cases with the shells of the Foraminifera ; and we have seen that wherever the shell is but a single unit or single chamber, its form may be explained in general by the laws of surface tension: the assumption being that the little mass of protoplasm which makes the simple shell behaves as a fluid drop, the form of which is perpetuated when the protoplasm acquires its solid covering. Thus the spherical Orbulinae and the flask-shaped Lagenae represent drops in equilibrium, under various conditions of freedom or constraint; while the irregular, amoeboid body of Astrorhiza is a manifestation not of equilibrium, but of a varying and fluctuating distribution of surface energy. When the foraminiferal shell becomes multilocular, the same general principles continue to hold; the growing protoplasm increases drop by drop, and each successive drop has its particular phenomena of surface energy, manifested at its fluid surface, and tending to confer upon it a certain place in the system and a certain shape of its own.

Chapter XIII: The Shapes of Horns, and of Teeth or Tusks: with a Note on Torsion

We have had so much to say on the subject of shell-spirals that we must deal briefly with the analogous problems which are presented by the horns of sheep, goats, antelopes and other horned quadrupeds; and all the more, because these horn-spirals are on the whole less symmetrical, less easy of measurement than those of the shell, and in other ways also are less easy of investigation. Let us dispense altogether in this case with mathematics; and be content with a very simple account of the configuration of a horn.

A. Cylindrical Bravais–Tait Lattice (Fig. 325) B. Apical Capitulum: (8, 13) Parastichies 0 1 2 3 5 8 13 Divergence Δθ = 360°/φ² ≈ 137°30′28″ Intersecting Fibonacci parastichy families (8, 13)

Chapter XIV: On Leaf-Arrangement, or Phyllotaxis

The beautiful configurations produced by the orderly arrangement of leaves or florets on a stem have long been an object of admiration and curiosity. Leonardo da Vinci would seem, as Sir Theodore Cook tells us, to have been the first to record his thoughts upon this subject; but the old Greek and Egyptian geometers are not likely to have left unstudied or unobserved the spiral traces of the leaves upon a palm-stem, or the spiral curves of the petals of a lotus or the florets in a sunflower.

Chapter XV: On the Shapes of Eggs, and of Certain Other Hollow Structures

The eggs of birds and all other hard-shelled eggs, such as those of the tortoise and the crocodile, are simple solids of revolution; but they differ greatly in form, according to the configuration of the plane curve by the revolution of which the egg is, in a mathematical sense, generated. Some few eggs, such as those of the owl, the penguin, or the tortoise, are spherical or very nearly so; a few more, such as the grebe’s, the cormorant’s or the pelican’s, are approximately ellipsoidal, with symmetrical or nearly symmetrical ends, and somewhat similar are the so-called “cylindrical” eggs of the megapodes and the sand-grouse; the great majority, like the hen’s egg, are ovoid, a little blunter at one end than the other; and some, by an exaggeration of this lack of antero-posterior symmetry, are blunt at one end but characteristically pointed at the other, as is the case with the eggs of the guillemot and puffin, the sandpiper, plover and curlew. It is an obvious but by no means negligible fact that the egg, while often pointed, is never flattened or discoidal; it is a prolate, but never an oblate, spheroid.

A. Culmann's Fairbairn Crane B. Meyer's Trabecular Arch in Human Femur W W Solid amber: principal compression arches | Dashed red: orthogonal principal tension trajectories

Chapter XVI: On Form and Mechanical Efficiency

There is a certain large class of morphological problems of which we have not yet spoken, and of which we shall be able to say but little. Nevertheless they are so important, so full of deep theoretical significance, and are so bound up with the general question of form and of its determination as a result of growth, that an essay on growth and form is bound to take account of them, however imperfectly and briefly. The phenomena which I have in mind are just those many cases where adaptation, in the strictest sense, is obviously present, in the clearly demonstrable form of mechanical fitness for the exercise of some particular function or action which has become inseparable from the life and well-being of the organism.

A. Argyropelecus Olfersi (90° Cartesian) B. Sternoptyx diaphana (70° Oblique Shear) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 a b c d e f x' = x, y' = y (ω = 90°) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 a b c d e f x' = x + y cos 70°, y' = y sin 70° (ω = 70°)

Chapter XVII: On the Theory of Transformations, or the Comparison of Related Forms

ON THE THEORY OF TRANSFORMATIONS, OR THE COMPARISON OF RELATED FORMS


Scholarly Apparatus