Classical Synagoge Constructions (Books III, IV, V & VIII)

Alongside Book VII’s projective incidence canon, geometor.pappus.synagoge_demos brings four celebrated metric, affine, and isoperimetric propositions of Pappus’s Synagoge to life in 100% exact symbolic coordinates—paired directly with the four-track Greek/English Synagoge Book Codex.

1. Book III, Props. 28–30: Three Classical Means in One Semicircle

Given unequal positive segments $AD = a$ and $DC = b$ placed along diameter $AC$ of a semicircle centered at $O$ (Book III Codex, Hultsch I, pp. 68–84), construct_three_means(a, b) constructs the arithmetic mean $A$, geometric mean $G$, and harmonic mean $H$ inside a single diagram, together with the external harmonic conjugate $T$ where $(A, C; D, T) = -1$:

Exact Semicircle Means over $\mathbb{Q}$ and $\mathbb{Q}(\phi)$

Segments $(a, b)$

Arithmetic $A = |OB|$

Geometric $G = |DB|$

Harmonic $H = |BF|$

Conjugate $T$

$(9,\, 16)$

$\frac{25}{2}$

$12$

$\frac{288}{25}$

$\left(-\frac{225}{7},\, 0\right)$

$(4,\, 9)$

$\frac{13}{2}$

$6$

$\frac{72}{13}$

$\left(-\frac{36}{5},\, 0\right)$

$(1,\, \phi^2)$

$\frac{\phi + 2}{2}$

$\phi$

$\frac{2\phi}{\sqrt{5}}$

$(-\phi,\, 0)$

Synagoge III.5–16 — Arithmetic, Geometric, and Harmonic Means in One Semicircle ( O A ): y**2 + (x - 25/2)**2 - 625/4 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 F = (7641/625, 588/625) A = (0, 0) D = (9, 0) C = (25, 0) O = (25/2, 0) B = (9, 12) F A D C O B
step Place A $= (0, 0)$, D $= (9, 0)$, and C $= (25, 0)$ along diameter AC with midpoint O $= \left(\frac{25}{2}, 0\right)$ on semicircle ABC, so radius OB equals $A = \frac{25}{2}$.
step Erect ordinate DB perpendicular to AC meeting the semicircle at B $= (9, 12)$, yielding $G = \sqrt{9 \cdot 16} = 12$.
step Drop DF perpendicular to radius OB at foot F $= \left(\frac{7641}{625}, \frac{588}{625}\right)$: right-triangle similarity $\triangle ODB \sim \triangle DFB$ gives $|BF| = \frac{G^2}{A} = \frac{288}{25} = H$, while tangent BT meets AC at T $= \left(-\frac{225}{7}, 0\right)$ with $(A, C; D, T) = -1$.

On the golden diameter $(a, b) = (1, \phi^2)$, the geometric mean DB equals $\phi$ itself and the external tangent meets the diameter line at T $= (-\phi, 0)$:

Synagoge III — Golden Semicircle Means on (1, phi^2) with Harmonic Conjugate T = (-phi, 0) ( O A ): y**2 + (x - 5/4 - sqrt(5)/4)**2 - (sqrt(5)/4 + 5/4)**2 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 F = (sqrt(5)/5 + 6/5, sqrt(2)*(sqrt(2)/2 + sqrt(10)/2)/10) A = (0, 0) D = (1, 0) C = (sqrt(5)/2 + 5/2, 0) O = (sqrt(5)/4 + 5/4, 0) B = (1, sqrt(2)*(sqrt(2)/2 + sqrt(10)/2)/2) T = (-sqrt(5), 0) F A D C O B T

2. Book IV, Prop. 1: Equiaffine Parallelogram Area Theorem

In Book IV, Proposition 1 Hultsch I, pp. 176–179), Pappus generalizes Elements I.47 from squares on a right triangle to arbitrary outward parallelograms erected on two sides $AB, AC$ of any triangle $\triangle ABC$. If the outer sides produced meet at $H$, then the parallelogram constructed on base $BC$ with lateral vector equal and parallel to $\overrightarrow{HA}$ has signed area identically equal to the sum of the two side parallelograms:

\[\det(C - B,\; A - H) = \det(B - A,\; u) + \det(A - C,\; v) \quad \text{in } \mathbb{Z}[x_A, y_A, x_B, y_B, x_C, y_C, u_x, u_y, v_x, v_y].\]

verify_pappus_area_symbolic() proves this universal 10-variable polynomial identity directly in SymPy, while construct_pappus_area_theorem() models both the general scalene configuration ($13 + 15 = 28$) and Euclid’s $3$-$4$-$5$ Pythagorean specialization ($9 + 16 = 25$).

3. Book IV, Props. 14–18: Infinite Arbelos Tangent Circle Chain

In Book IV, Propositions 14–18 (Hultsch I, pp. 208–232), Pappus demonstrates the “ancient proposition” on the shoemaker’s knife (ἄρβηλος): for an infinite chain of circles $C_1, C_2, C_3, \dots$ inscribed tangent to the three bounding semicircles and successively to one another, the center altitude $y_n$ of the $n$-th circle above baseline $AC$ is $n$ times its diameter $d_n$:

\[r_n = \frac{R\,r_1\,r_2}{r_1 r_2 + n^2 R^2 \text{ (in reduced } \lambda\text{-form)}}, \qquad y_n = n\,d_n = 2n\,r_n \qquad (n = 1, 2, 3, \dots),\]

and every center $K_n$ lies on a single fixed ellipse with foci at $O_0$ and $O_1$.

Synagoge IV.14–18 — Pappus's Arbelos Tangent Circle Chain (y_n = n d_n) ( O0 A ): y**2 + (x - 3)**2 - 9 = 0 ( O1 A ): y**2 + (x - 2)**2 - 4 = 0 ( O2 D ): y**2 + (x - 5)**2 - 1 = 0 ( K1 X1 ): (x - 30/7)**2 + (y - 12/7)**2 - 36/49 = 0 ( K2 X2 ): (x - 3)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 9/25 = 0 ( K3 X3 ): (x - 2)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 4/25 = 0 ( K4 X4 ): (x - 15/11)**2 + (y - 24/11)**2 - 9/121 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 P3 = (2, 0) O2 = (5, 0) X1 = (36/7, 12/7) P1 = (30/7, 0) X2 = (18/5, 12/5) X3 = (12/5, 12/5) X4 = (18/11, 24/11) P4 = (15/11, 0) A = (0, 0) D = (4, 0) C = (6, 0) P2 = (3, 0) K1 = (30/7, 12/7) K2 = (3, 12/5) K3 = (2, 12/5) K4 = (15/11, 24/11) P3 O2 P1 P4 A D C P2 K1 K2 K3 K4
step Construct outer semicircle (O0, A) of radius $R = 3$ and inner semicircles (O1, A) ($r_1 = 2$) and (O2, D) ($r_2 = 1$) along baseline AC.
step Inscribe base circle C1 at K1 $= \left(\frac{30}{7}, \frac{12}{7}\right)$ with diameter $d_1 = \frac{12}{7}$ and altitude P1K1 $= 1 \cdot d_1$.
step Inscribe C2 at K2 $= \left(3, \frac{12}{5}\right)$ ($y_2 = 2\,d_2$), C3 at K3 $= \left(2, \frac{12}{5}\right)$ ($y_3 = 3\,d_3$), and C4 at K4 $= \left(\frac{15}{11}, \frac{24}{11}\right)$ ($y_4 = 4\,d_4$), tracing the rational focal ellipse through all centers.

4. Book V, Prop. 1 & Book VIII, Prop. 23: Honeycomb Isoperimetry & Seven Hexagons

In Book V (Hultsch I, pp. 304–312) and Book VIII, Proposition 23 (Hultsch III, pp. 1096–1102), Pappus proves:

  1. Around any gapless planar vertex tiled by $k \ge 3$ congruent regular $n$-gons, $k \cdot \frac{(n - 2)\pi}{n} = 2\pi \implies (n - 2)(k - 2) = 4$, uniquely admitting $(n, k) \in \{(3, 6), (4, 4), (6, 3)\}$.

  2. At equal perimeter $P$, exact areas satisfy $A_6 : A_4 : A_3 = \frac{P^2}{8\sqrt{3}} : \frac{P^2}{16} : \frac{P^2}{12\sqrt{3}} = 3\sqrt{3} : 4 : 3$, so $A_6 / A_3 = \frac{3}{2}$ and $A_6 > A_4 > A_3$.

  3. One central regular hexagon of side $s_6$ surrounded by six congruent petal hexagons has its twelve outer vertices concyclic on a circle of exact radius $R = s_6\sqrt{7}$ (by the Law of Cosines on the $120^\circ$ triangle with legs $s_6$ and $2s_6$: $R^2 = s_6^2 + 4s_6^2 + 2s_6^2 = 7s_6^2$).