Book V · On the Geometric Forethought of Bees & Isoperimetry

Μαθηματικὴ Συναγωγή Ε΄ — Pappus of Alexandria, ed. Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. I, pp. 304–336)

Note

Edition Track (English): Complete critical English edition of Book V’s opening masterpiece: the Preface on the Sagacity of Bees and Propositions 1–10 establishing the planar isoperimetric theorem ($A_6 > A_4 > A_3$). Switch tracks above for Greek (Hultsch 1876), Summary, or Notes.

ΠΑΠΠΟΥ ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΕΩΣ ΣΥΝΑΓΩΓΗΣ Ε΄
PAPPI ALEXANDRINI COLLECTIONIS LIBER QUINTUS

Author: Pappus of Alexandria (fl. c. 320–340 CE)
Addressee: Megethius
Critical Greek Edition: Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. I, Berlin: Weidmann, 1876, pp. 304–473)
Latin Editio Princeps: Federico Commandino (Pesaro, 1588)

“The bees, possessing no instruction from geometry, fashion the honeycombs in which they store the celestial dew according to a marvelous geometric forethought.”

—Pappus of Alexandria, Synagoge Book V, Chapter 1


Table of Contents

Synagoge V.1 & VIII.23 — Honeycomb Isoperimetry (P = 12) and Seven Inscribed Hexagons ( H0 N ): y**2 + (x - 3)**2 - 28 = 0 X11 = (5, 2*sqrt(3)) N = (4, 3*sqrt(3)) X13 = (2, 3*sqrt(3)) X14 = (1, 2*sqrt(3)) X21 = (8, sqrt(3)) X22 = (7, 2*sqrt(3)) X26 = (7, 0) X31 = (8, -sqrt(3)) X35 = (5, -2*sqrt(3)) X36 = (7, -2*sqrt(3)) X44 = (1, -2*sqrt(3)) X45 = (2, -3*sqrt(3)) X46 = (4, -3*sqrt(3)) X53 = (-1, 0) X54 = (-2, -sqrt(3)) X55 = (-1, -2*sqrt(3)) X63 = (-1, 2*sqrt(3)) X64 = (-2, sqrt(3)) T1 = (-10, -5) T2 = (-6, -5) T3 = (-8, -5 + 2*sqrt(3)) Q1 = (-19/2, 3/2) Q2 = (-13/2, 3/2) Q3 = (-13/2, 9/2) Q4 = (-19/2, 9/2) V1 = (5, 0) V2 = (4, sqrt(3)) V3 = (2, sqrt(3)) V4 = (1, 0) V5 = (2, -sqrt(3)) V6 = (4, -sqrt(3)) H0 = (3, 0) N T1 T2 T3 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 H0

Propositions 1–10: The Planar Isoperimetric Chain

Proposition 1 (Hultsch I, pp. 308–312): Of all equilateral and equiangular rectilinear polygons having an equal perimeter $P$, that which has the more angles encloses the greater area; in particular, for equal perimeter $P = 12$, the regular hexagon V1..V6 ($s_6 = 2$, area $6\sqrt{3}$) strictly exceeds both the square Q1..Q4 ($s_4 = 3$, area $9$) and the equilateral triangle T1..T3 ($s_3 = 4$, area $4\sqrt{3}$), while six surrounding hexagonal cells C1–C6 tile seamlessly around H0 inside circle (H0, N) of radius H0N $= s_6\sqrt{7}$.

Book V · Philological & Mathematical Notes

Pappus’s treatment of isoperimetric figures in Book V draws directly upon the lost treatise On Isoperimetric Figures by Zenodorus (c. 200–140 BCE). Zenodorus’s work is preserved today through two independent channels: Book V of Pappus’s Synagoge and Theon of Alexandria’s commentary on Ptolemy’s Almagest (Book I).