The Three Classical Means & Their Unified Semicircle Construction

Synagoge Book III, Chs. 28–43 (Props. 28–30, Hultsch I, pp. 68–84) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek

After our friend the philosopher Hierius inquired further concerning proportional means, we set out the ancient doctrine of medieties (μεσότητες) expounded by the Pythagoreans, Eratosthenes, and Nicomachus. Three primary proportions stand first and most ancient among all ten:

  • A triple $(a, m, b)$ is in arithmetic proportion (ἀριθμητικὴ μεσότης) whenever the first exceeds the second by the very same difference by which the second exceeds the third, so that $(a - m) : (m - b) = a : a = 1 : 1$, whence $A = \frac{a + b}{2}$.

  • A triple $(a, m, b)$ is in geometric proportion (γεωμετρικὴ μεσότης, proportion strictly so called) whenever the first has to the second the same ratio that the second has to the third, $(a - m) : (m - b) = a : m = m : b$, whence $G = \sqrt{ab}$.

  • A triple $(a, m, b)$ is in harmonic proportion (ἁρμονικὴ μεσότης) whenever the excess of the first over the second has to the excess of the second over the third the ratio of the first extreme to the third extreme:

    \[\frac{a - H}{H - b} = \frac{a}{b} \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad H = \frac{2ab}{a + b}.\]

How one may exhibit all three means together inside a single semicircle—establishing at one glance both the fundamental identity $A \cdot H = G^2$ and the strict ordering $A \ge G \ge H$ (with equality if and only if $a = b$)—is demonstrated as follows (Chs. 40–43, Hultsch I pp. 72, 80–84).

Synagoge III.5–16 — Arithmetic, Geometric, and Harmonic Means in One Semicircle ( O A ): y**2 + (x - 25/2)**2 - 625/4 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 F = (7641/625, 588/625) A = (0, 0) D = (9, 0) C = (25, 0) O = (25/2, 0) B = (9, 12) F A D C O B
Let two unequal straight segments AD $= a$ and DC $= b$ be placed end-to-end along diameter AC of semicircle ABC with center O. Erect DB perpendicular to AC meeting the circumference at B, join radius OB, and drop DF perpendicular to OB at F. Then radius OB is the arithmetic mean $A$, ordinate DB is the geometric mean $G$, and segment BF cut off from the vertex B is the harmonic mean $H$ of $a$ and $b$; moreover, the tangent BT at B meets diameter AC produced at the external harmonic conjugate T satisfying $(A, C; D, T) = -1$.
step Lay out A $= (0, 0)$, division point D $= (9, 0)$, and C $= (25, 0)$ along diameter AC ($a = 9$, $b = 16$). Bisect AC at center O $= \left(\frac{25}{2}, 0\right)$ and describe semicircle ABC. Because $OA = OC = OB$, radius OB equals $\frac{a + b}{2} = \frac{25}{2}$, which is the arithmetic mean $A$.
step Erect the perpendicular at D to meet semicircle ABC at B $= (9, 12)$. By [III.31], $\angle ABC$ in triangle ABC is right, so by [VI.8] and [VI.13] the altitude DB is the mean proportional between $AD$ and $DC$: $DB^2 = AD \cdot DC = ab = 144$, giving the geometric mean $G = 12$.
step

Join radius OB and drop DF perpendicular to OB at foot F $= \left(\frac{7641}{625}, \frac{588}{625}\right)$. Since right triangles $\triangle ODB$ and $\triangle DFB$ share acute angle $\angle OBD$ at B, they are equiangular ([VI.8]), whence $OB : DB = DB : BF$. Therefore

\[A \cdot BF = OB \cdot BF = DB^2 = G^2 = ab \quad \Longrightarrow \quad BF = \frac{2ab}{a + b} = \frac{288}{25},\]

proving that BF is the exact harmonic mean $H$, and that $G$ is itself the geometric mean between $A$ and $H$ ($A \cdot H = G^2$).

step Observe the nested right triangles $\triangle ODB$ (hypotenuse OB, leg DB) and $\triangle DFB$ (hypotenuse DB, leg BF). Because the hypotenuse of a right triangle strictly exceeds either leg ([I.19]) whenever D $\neq$ O, we read off immediately $OB > DB > BF$, i.e., $A > G > H$ ($\frac{25}{2} > 12 > \frac{288}{25}$), collapsing to equality $A = G = H$ when $a = b$.
step Draw tangent BT perpendicular to radius OB, meeting diameter AC produced at T $= \left(-\frac{225}{7}, 0\right)$. Parallelism of DF and BT transfers the ratio on OB onto the diameter line, yielding the four-point harmonic range $(A, C; D, T) = -1$ that recurs in projective form in Book VII Prop. 131.