Chapter VI: Pascal’s Theorem

Kapitel VI: Der Pascalsche Satz — David Hilbert (1899 / 1902) — §§ 31–35

Chapter VI brings the projective-algebraic hierarchy to its climax by isolating the exact axiomatic and algebraic meaning of Pascal's (Pappus's) Theorem when Congruence (`IV`) is omitted:

  • § 31 — Two Fundamental Theorems on Pappus/Pascal (Theorems 36–37): Announces two complementary results in 3D space without Congruence: 1. Theorem 36: Pappus/Pascal is provable from I, II, III, V (i.e., with Archimedes’s Axiom, even without Congruence!). 2. Theorem 37: Pappus/Pascal is unprovable from I, II, III alone (when both Congruence IV and Archimedes V are dropped).

  • § 32 — Hilbert’s Commutativity Theorem for Archimedean Skew-Fields (Theorem 38): Proves a landmark theorem of pure algebra: every Archimedean ordered division ring is necessarily commutative! Assuming $a > 0, b > 0$, and $ab - ba > 0$, Hilbert traps $a$ and $b$ between consecutive multiples $md < a < (m+1)d$ and $nd < b < (n+1)d$ using Archimedes’s Axiom (17) and shows $ab - ba < (m + n + 1)d^2 < (a + b + 1)c = ab - ba$, an outright contradiction!

  • § 33 — Hilbert’s Non-Commutative Twist Laurent Skew-Field $\Omega(s, t)$ (Theorem 39): Constructs the first explicit example in mathematics of an ordered non-Archimedean skew-field (Theorem 39): formal Laurent series $S = s^m T_0 + s^{m+1} T_1 + \cdots$ whose coefficients $T_k = r_0 t^n + r_1 t^{n+1} + \cdots$ are formal Laurent series in $t$ over $\mathbb{Q}$, governed by the non-commutative twist relation

    $$ts = 2st,$$

    and ordered lexicographically by the leading rational coefficient $r_0$ of $T_0$.

  • §§ 34–35 — Non-Pascalian Geometry and Intersection Completeness: Building 3-space over $\Omega(s, t)$ via § 29 immediately proves Theorem 37, exhibiting a consistent 3D Non-Pascalian Geometry (which by Theorem 36 is necessarily non-Archimedean). Conversely, § 35 proves that every planar incidence/intersection theorem holding under I–V reduces synthetically to a finite combination of Desargues’s and Pascal’s (Pappus’s) theorems without needing Congruence!

Sections

§ 31: Two Theorems Concerning the Possibility of Proving Pascal’s Theorem

As is well known, Desargues’s theorem (theorem 32) may be demonstrated by the aid of axioms I, II, III; that is to say, by the use, essentially, of the axioms of space. In § ! 23, we have shown that the demonstration of this theorem without the aid of the space axioms of group I and without the axioms of congruence (group IV) is impossible, even if we make use of the axiom of Archimedes.

§ 33: The Commutative Law of Multiplication for a Non-Archimedean Number System

Theorem 39. For a non-archimedean number system, the commutative law of multiplication is not a necessary consequence of the remaining laws of operation; that is to say, there exists a system of numbers possessing the properties 1–11, 13–16 mentioned in § ! 13, but for which the commutative law (12) of multiplication is not valid. A desarguesian number system, in the sense of § ! 28, is such a system.

§ 34: Proof of the Two Propositions Concerning Pascal’s Theorem (Non-Pascalian Geometry)

If, in a geometry of space, all of the axioms I, II, III are fulfilled, then Desargues’s theorem (theorem 32) is also valid, and, consequently, according to §§ 24–26, pp. 79–89, it is possible to introduce into this geometry an algebra of segments for which the rules 1–11, 13–16 of § ! 13 are all valid. If we assume now that the axiom (V) of Archimedes is valid for our geometry, then evidently Archimedes’s theorem (theorem 17 of § ! 13) also holds for our algebra of segments, and, consequently, by virtue of theorem 38, the commutative law of multiplication is valid. Since, however, the definition of the product of two segments, as introduced in § ! 24 (figure 42) and which is the definition here also under discussion, agrees with the definition in § ! 15 (figure 22), it follows from the construction made in § ! 15 that the commutative law of multiplication is here nothing else than Pascal’s theorem. Consequently, the validity of theorem 36 is established.

§ 35: The Demonstration, by Means of the Theorems of Pascal and Desargues, of Any Theorem Relating to Points of Intersection

Every proposition relating to points of intersection in a plane has necessarily The form: Select, first of all, an arbitrary system of points and straight lines satisfying respectively the condition that certain ones of these points are situated on certain ones of the straight lines. If, in some known manner, we construct the straight lines joining the given points and determine the points of intersection of the given lines, we shall obtain finally a definite system of three straight lines, of which our proposition asserts that they all pass through the same point.