f. § 34 · p. 110

§ 34: Proof of the Two Propositions Concerning Pascal’s Theorem (Non-Pascalian Geometry)

David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)

If, in a geometry of space, all of the axioms I, II, III are fulfilled, then Desargues’s theorem (theorem 32) is also valid, and, consequently, according to §§ 24–26, pp. 79–89, it is possible to introduce into this geometry an algebra of segments for which the rules 1–11, 13–16 of § ! 13 are all valid. If we assume now that the axiom (V) of Archimedes is valid for our geometry, then evidently Archimedes’s theorem (theorem 17 of § ! 13) also holds for our algebra of segments, and, consequently, by virtue of theorem 38, the commutative law of multiplication is valid. Since, however, the definition of the product of two segments, as introduced in § ! 24 (figure 42) and which is the definition here also under discussion, agrees with the definition in § ! 15 (figure 22), it follows from the construction made in § ! 15 that the commutative law of multiplication is here nothing else than Pascal’s theorem. Consequently, the validity of theorem 36 is established.

In order to demonstrate theorem 37, let us consider again the desarguesian number system $\Omega(s, t)$ introduced in $\S$ 33, and construct, in the manner described in $\S$ 29, a geometry of space for which all of the axioms I, II, III are fulfilled. However, Pascal’s theorem will not hold for this geometry; for, the commutative law of multiplication is not valid in the desarguesian number system $\Omega(s, t)$. According to theorem 36, the non-pascalian geometry is then necessarily also a non-archimedean geometry.

By adopting the hypothesis we have, it is evident that we cannot demonstrate Pascal’s theorem, providing we regard our geometry of space as a part of a geometry of an arbitrary number of dimensions in which, besides the points, straight lines, and planes, still other linear elements are present, and providing there exists for these elements a corresponding system of axioms of connection and of order, as well as the axiom of parallels.