Proposition 17 [ιζ΄ · Prop. XXV]

If there be three magnitudes, and the first be greater than the second by a given magnitude than in ratio, and the third be also greater than the same second by a given magnitude than in ratio, then either the first has a given ratio to the third, or one is greater than the other by a given magnitude than in ratio.

Functional Signature: Given((A - d1):B = k1, (C - d2):B = k2) -> Determined(Ratio(A:C) | GreaterThanInRatio(A, C)) · Dependencies: [Data 8], [Data 14], [V.11]

Let there be three magnitudes $AB, CD, E$, and let each of $AB$ and $E$ be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $CD$ (in Menge’s order: first and third each greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the second, or first and second to the third). Specifically, let $AB$ and $CD$ each be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $E$. I say that $AB$ and $CD$ either have a given ratio to one another, or one is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the other.

From $AB$ subtract the given magnitude $AF$ ([Data Def. 11]), so that $FB : E$ is given; and from $CD$ subtract the given magnitude $CG$, so that $GD : E$ is given. Since both $FB$ and $GD$ have given ratios to $E$, the ratio $FB : GD$ is given ([Data 8]). And to the two magnitudes $FB$ and $GD$, having a given ratio to one another, the given magnitudes $AF$ and $CG$ have been added; therefore the wholes $AB$ and $CD$ either have a given ratio to one another, or one is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the other ([Data 14]).