Notes — Two Mean Proportionals & Wantzel’s Cubic Impossibility

2. Two Mean Proportionals & Wantzel’s Cubic Impossibility

In Plato’s mechanical carpenter’s square (Fig. 50, p. 163), setting right-angled legs $gb = g$ and $be = e$ along orthogonal axes with right angles at $c = (0, c)$ and $d = (-d, 0)$ forces altitude-on-hypotenuse similarity (Euclid VI.8) in $\triangle gcd$ and $\triangle cde$:

$$\frac{g}{c} = \frac{c}{d} = \frac{d}{e} \implies c^2 = gd, \quad d^2 = ce \implies c^3 = g^2 e.$$

Taking $g = 1$ and $e = 2$ yields $c = \sqrt[3]{2}$ and $d = \sqrt[3]{4}$, so $operatorname{Vol}(c) / operatorname{Vol}(g) = c^3 / g^3 = 2$ identically! Because $x^3 - 2$ is irreducible over $\mathbb{Q}$ of degree $3 \neq 2^k$, Pierre Laurent Wantzel (wantzel:1837) and Felix Klein (klein:1895) proved why all three of Dürer’s Book IV constructions (Sporus’s graduated ruler, Plato’s sliding square, and Hero’s pivoting straightedge) necessarily employ neusis or mechanical linkage beyond unmarked straightedge and compass.