Book V — Color-Coded Symbolic Algebra of Eudoxian Proportions

Abstract Magnitude Tokens & Equimultiple Calculus (Pickering pp. 153–212, Leaves 187–246)

In Book V, Eudoxus and Euclid generalize ratio and proportion from spatial lines to arbitrary continuous magnitudes of the same kind—lengths, planar areas, polyhedral volumes, or angles. Recognizing that line diagrams obscure this universality, Oliver Byrne abandons spatial figures across pages 153–212 and introduces typed colored magnitude symbols (, , , ).

Book V, Definition V — Colored Magnitude Tokens & Equimultiple Criterion BOOK V · DEFINITION V — EUDOXIAN PROPORTION (p. 154) : ∷ : (same ratio) = If M ⊏ , = , ⊐ m ⟹ M ⊏ , = , ⊐ m Universal for all integer equimultiples M, m ∈ ℕ⁺
**Book V, Definition V (p. 154).** Byrne's Chiswick Press colored magnitude tokens (:byrne-mag:`red circle` : :byrne-mag:`yellow square` :byrne-op:`prop` :byrne-mag:`blue diamond` : :byrne-mag:`black shield`) and universal integer equimultiple test $M, m \in \mathbb{N}^+$.

Byrne’s Typed Magnitude Registers & Definition V (p. 154)

  • First magnitude: (:byrne-mag:`red circle`)

  • Second magnitude: (:byrne-mag:`yellow square`)

  • Third magnitude: (:byrne-mag:`blue diamond`)

  • Fourth magnitude: (:byrne-mag:`black shield`)

Four magnitudes are in the same ratio, : ∷ : , when for every pair of positive integer equimultiples $M, m \in \mathbb{N}^+$:

  • if $M \cdot$ ⊏ $m \cdot$ , then $M \cdot$ ⊏ $m \cdot$ ;

  • if $M \cdot$ = $m \cdot$ , then $M \cdot$ = $m \cdot$ ; and

  • if $M \cdot$ ⊐ $m \cdot$ , then $M \cdot$ ⊐ $m \cdot$ .

Propositions in Book V

Book V, Prop. XI — Transitivity of Ratios (Pickering p. 175) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XI — TRANSITIVITY OF RATIOS (p. 175) Let : = : and : = : M ⊏,=,⊐ m ⟺ M ⊏,=,⊐ m ⟺ M ∴ : = : Ratios that are the same to the same ratio are the same to each other

Proposition V.11 — Transitivity of Ratios

Ratios that are the same to the same ratio, are the same to each other.

Book V, Prop. XVI — Alternando (Pickering p. 181) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XVI — ALTERNANDO (p. 181) Let : ∷ : M : M ∷ m : m (V.15, V.14) ∴ : ∷ : Interchanging middle terms preserves Eudoxian proportion

Proposition V.16 — Alternando (Alternate Proportion)

If four magnitudes of the same kind be proportionals, they are also proportionals when taken alternately.

Book V, Prop. XVIII — Componendo (Pickering p. 185) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XVIII — COMPONENDO (p. 185) Let : ∷ : Separando (V.17) + V.9 ⟹ = ∴ + : ∷ + : Magnitudes proportional separately remain proportional jointly

Proposition V.18 — Componendo (Joint Proportion)

If magnitudes, taken separately, be proportionals, they shall also be proportionals when taken jointly: that is, if the first be to the second as the third is to the fourth, the first and second together shall be to the second as the third and fourth together is to the fourth.

Book V, Prop. XXII — Ex Aequali (Pickering pp. 193–194) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XXII — EX AEQUALI (pp. 193–194) 1st triple: , , 2nd triple: , , : ∷ : and : ∷ : ∴ : ∷ : (ex æquali) Elimination of middle magnitudes across equimultiple chains

Proposition V.22 — Ex Aequali (Equality of Distance)

If there be any number of magnitudes, and as many others, which, taken two and two in order, have the same ratio; the first shall have to the last of the first magnitudes the same ratio which the first of the others has to the last of the same.