Proposition V.11 — Transitivity of Ratios

Book V, Proposition XI. Theorem (Pickering p. 175 · G.271)

Ratios that are the same to the same ratio, are the same to each other.

Book V, Prop. XI — Transitivity of Ratios (Pickering p. 175) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XI — TRANSITIVITY OF RATIOS (p. 175) Let : = : and : = : M ⊏,=,⊐ m ⟺ M ⊏,=,⊐ m ⟺ M ∴ : = : Ratios that are the same to the same ratio are the same to each other
**Pickering p. 175 Tableau.** Transitivity of Eudoxian ratios across three colored magnitude pairs.

Given. Let : ∷ : and : ∷ : ;

then will : ∷ : .

Demonstration (:just:`V.def.5`).

For arbitrary positive integers $M, m$:

If $M \cdot$ is ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ,

then $M \cdot$ is correspondingly ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ([V.def.5]),

and therefore $M \cdot$ is correspondingly ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ([V.def.5]);

∴ if $M \cdot$ is ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ , then $M \cdot$ is ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ,

and ∴ ([V.def.5]) : ∷ : . Q.E.D.


See Commentary on Proposition V.11.