Proposition V.16 — Alternando (Alternate Proportion)

Book V, Proposition XVI. Theorem (Pickering p. 181 · G.276)

If four magnitudes of the same kind be proportionals, they are also proportionals when taken alternately.

Book V, Prop. XVI — Alternando (Pickering p. 181) BOOK V · PROPOSITION XVI — ALTERNANDO (p. 181) Let : ∷ : M : M ∷ m : m (V.15, V.14) ∴ : ∷ : Interchanging middle terms preserves Eudoxian proportion
**Pickering p. 181 Tableau (*Alternando*).** Interchanging the middle colored magnitudes preserves proportion.

Given. Let : ∷ : ;

then : ∷ : .

Demonstration (:just:`V.15`, :just:`V.11`, :just:`V.14`, :just:`V.def.5`).

For $M \cdot$ : $M \cdot$ ∷ : ([V.15]),

and ∴ $M \cdot$ : $M \cdot$ ∷ : (hyp. and [V.11]);

also $m \cdot$ : $m \cdot$ ∷ : ([V.15]),

∴ $M \cdot$ : $M \cdot$ ∷ $m \cdot$ : $m \cdot$ ([V.11]).

Hence if $M \cdot$ is ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ,

then $M \cdot$ is correspondingly ⊏, =, or ⊐ $m \cdot$ ([V.14]);

∴ ([V.def.5]) : ∷ : . Q.E.D.


See Commentary on Proposition V.16.