The Multi-Line Locus Problem & the Pappus–Guldinus Centroid Rule

Synagoge Book VII, Chs. 36–42 (Hultsch II, pp. 676–683) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek

In reviewing Apollonius's Conics, Pappus records the celebrated Three- and Four-Line Locus (ὁ ἐπὶ τρεῖς καὶ τέσσαρας γραμμὰς τόπος, pp. 676–680): if straight lines are drawn from a point at given angles to three (or four) lines given in position, and the rectangle contained by two of them bears a given ratio to the square on the third (or to the rectangle contained by the remaining two), the locus of the point is a conic section. When generalized to five, six, or arbitrarily many $n$ lines using compound ratios (λόγοι συγκείμενοι)—so that no impossible dimension beyond the cube or solid parallelepiped need be invoked—the ancients left the higher locus unconstructed, bequeathing the exact challenge through which René Descartes launched analytic geometry in La Géométrie (1637).

Immediately thereafter (Hultsch II, p. 682), Pappus announces his universal Centroid Theorem for Solids and Surfaces of Revolution (rediscovered thirteen centuries later by Paul Guldin):

Figures generated by a complete revolution of a plane lamina about an axis not cutting it have to one another the **ratio compounded* of the ratio of the revolving areas and the ratio of the straight lines drawn perpendicularly from their centers of gravity to the axes of revolution—that is, the ratio of the circumferences traced by their centers of gravity:*

\[\frac{V_1}{V_2} = \left(\frac{A_1}{A_2}\right)\left(\frac{\bar{r}_1}{\bar{r}_2}\right) \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad V = A \cdot (2\pi \bar{r}), \qquad S = L \cdot (2\pi \bar{r}).\]