Propositions 1–10: The Planar Isoperimetric Chain

Synagoge Book V, Props. 1–10 (Hultsch I, pp. 308–336, extending Zenodorus) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek

Synagoge V.1 & VIII.23 — Honeycomb Isoperimetry (P = 12) and Seven Inscribed Hexagons ( H0 N ): y**2 + (x - 3)**2 - 28 = 0 X11 = (5, 2*sqrt(3)) N = (4, 3*sqrt(3)) X13 = (2, 3*sqrt(3)) X14 = (1, 2*sqrt(3)) X21 = (8, sqrt(3)) X22 = (7, 2*sqrt(3)) X26 = (7, 0) X31 = (8, -sqrt(3)) X35 = (5, -2*sqrt(3)) X36 = (7, -2*sqrt(3)) X44 = (1, -2*sqrt(3)) X45 = (2, -3*sqrt(3)) X46 = (4, -3*sqrt(3)) X53 = (-1, 0) X54 = (-2, -sqrt(3)) X55 = (-1, -2*sqrt(3)) X63 = (-1, 2*sqrt(3)) X64 = (-2, sqrt(3)) T1 = (-10, -5) T2 = (-6, -5) T3 = (-8, -5 + 2*sqrt(3)) Q1 = (-19/2, 3/2) Q2 = (-13/2, 3/2) Q3 = (-13/2, 9/2) Q4 = (-19/2, 9/2) V1 = (5, 0) V2 = (4, sqrt(3)) V3 = (2, sqrt(3)) V4 = (1, 0) V5 = (2, -sqrt(3)) V6 = (4, -sqrt(3)) H0 = (3, 0) N T1 T2 T3 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 H0
Proposition 1 (Hultsch I, pp. 308–312): Of all equilateral and equiangular rectilinear polygons having an equal perimeter $P$, that which has the more angles encloses the greater area; in particular, for equal perimeter $P = 12$, the regular hexagon V1..V6 ($s_6 = 2$, area $6\sqrt{3}$) strictly exceeds both the square Q1..Q4 ($s_4 = 3$, area $9$) and the equilateral triangle T1..T3 ($s_3 = 4$, area $4\sqrt{3}$), while six surrounding hexagonal cells C1–C6 tile seamlessly around H0 inside circle (H0, N) of radius H0N $= s_6\sqrt{7}$.
step

Compare any two isoperimetric regular polygons of $m$ and $n$ sides with $n > m$ (e.g., hexagon $n = 6$ vs. square $m = 4$ or triangle $m = 3$). Subdivide each polygon from its center into $n$ (respectively $m$) congruent isosceles triangles whose bases sum to the common perimeter $P$; then each polygon’s area equals half its perimeter multiplied by its apothem (κάθετος, perpendicular from the center to a side):

\[\operatorname{Area}_n = \frac{1}{2}\,P\,a_n, \qquad \operatorname{Area}_m = \frac{1}{2}\,P\,a_m.\]

Hence proving $\operatorname{Area}_n > \operatorname{Area}_m$ reduces to proving that the apothem $a_n$ strictly exceeds $a_m$!

step Superimpose half-side right triangles sharing equal central-angle-to-tan comparison (Props. 1–2, Hultsch I pp. 308–316, invoking the radian/sector tangent inequality proved rigorously via circular sectors in Prop. 3—the exact companion to Ptolemy’s chord-arc inequality in geometor/ptolemy): because the half-central angle $\frac{\pi}{n} < \frac{\pi}{m}$ satisfies $\frac{\tan(\pi/m)}{\tan(\pi/n)} > \frac{n}{m}$, the half-bases $\frac{P}{2n}$ and $\frac{P}{2m}$ force $a_n = \frac{P}{2n \tan(\pi/n)} > \frac{P}{2m \tan(\pi/m)} = a_m$.
step

Evaluate explicitly at common perimeter $P = 12$ on the left of the diagram:

  • Equilateral triangle T1T2T3 ($s_3 = 4$): $\operatorname{Area}_3 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}(4)^2 = 4\sqrt{3} \approx 6.9282$.

  • Square Q1Q2Q3Q4 ($s_4 = 3$): $\operatorname{Area}_4 = 3^2 = 9$.

  • Regular hexagon V1..V6 ($s_6 = 2$): $\operatorname{Area}_6 = \frac{3\sqrt{3}}{2}(2)^2 = 6\sqrt{3} \approx 10.3923$.

The exact algebraic ratios $\frac{\operatorname{Area}_6}{\operatorname{Area}_3} = \frac{3}{2}$ and $\frac{\operatorname{Area}_6}{\operatorname{Area}_4} = \frac{2\sqrt{3}}{3}$ (whose square is $\frac{12}{9} = \frac{4}{3} > 1$) prove without decimal approximation that the hexagon stores $50\%$ more honey than the triangle and $\frac{2\sqrt{3}}{3} \approx 15.47\%$ more honey than the square for the exact same wax perimeter!

step

Proceeding through Propositions 2–10 (Hultsch I pp. 312–336), Pappus completes the planar extremal proof:

  • Prop. 2: A circle of perimeter $P$ has area $\frac{P^2}{4\pi}$ strictly greater than any regular polygon of the same perimeter: circumscribing a similar regular polygon around the circle gives area $\frac{1}{2} P_{\text{circ}} R$, and since the circumscribed polygon’s perimeter strictly exceeds the circle’s circumference (Archimedes, On the Sphere and Cylinder I), scaling down to common perimeter $P$ shrinks the polygon’s apothem strictly below $R$.

  • Props. 4–6: Among triangles on the same base with equal sum of the remaining two sides, the isosceles triangle has the greatest area; consequently, among all $n$-gons of given perimeter, any maximum-area $n$-gon must be equilateral.

  • Props. 7–10: Similarly, among equilateral polygons of given perimeter and side count, the equiangular one encloses greater area than one that is not equiangular—completing the chain $\text{irregular } n\text{-gon} < \text{regular } n\text{-gon} < \text{regular } (n+1)\text{-gon} < \text{circle}$.

step On the right of the diagram, central cell V1..V6 centered at H0 is surrounded without gaps by six congruent hexagonal cells C1, C2, C3, C4, C5, C6, all inscribed cleanly inside circle (H0, N) of radius H0N $= s_6\sqrt{7} = 2\sqrt{7}$, anticipating Book VIII Proposition 23.

In the spatial second half of Book V (Props. 11–43, Hultsch I pp. 336–473), Pappus compares the sphere and regular polyhedra of equal surface area and preserves in Chapter 34 (Prop. 19, pp. 352–358) the **sole surviving ancient Greek enumeration of all thirteen Archimedean semi-regular solids*.*