Propositions 1–10: The Planar Isoperimetric Chain¶
Synagoge Book V, Props. 1–10 (Hultsch I, pp. 308–336, extending Zenodorus) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek
Compare any two isoperimetric regular polygons of $m$ and $n$ sides with $n > m$ (e.g., hexagon $n = 6$ vs. square $m = 4$ or triangle $m = 3$). Subdivide each polygon from its center into $n$ (respectively $m$) congruent isosceles triangles whose bases sum to the common perimeter $P$; then each polygon’s area equals half its perimeter multiplied by its apothem (κάθετος, perpendicular from the center to a side):
Hence proving $\operatorname{Area}_n > \operatorname{Area}_m$ reduces to proving that the apothem $a_n$ strictly exceeds $a_m$!
geometor/ptolemy): because the half-central angle $\frac{\pi}{n} < \frac{\pi}{m}$ satisfies $\frac{\tan(\pi/m)}{\tan(\pi/n)} > \frac{n}{m}$, the half-bases $\frac{P}{2n}$ and $\frac{P}{2m}$ force $a_n = \frac{P}{2n \tan(\pi/n)} > \frac{P}{2m \tan(\pi/m)} = a_m$.Evaluate explicitly at common perimeter $P = 12$ on the left of the diagram:
Equilateral triangle T1T2T3 ($s_3 = 4$): $\operatorname{Area}_3 = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}(4)^2 = 4\sqrt{3} \approx 6.9282$.
Square Q1Q2Q3Q4 ($s_4 = 3$): $\operatorname{Area}_4 = 3^2 = 9$.
Regular hexagon V1..V6 ($s_6 = 2$): $\operatorname{Area}_6 = \frac{3\sqrt{3}}{2}(2)^2 = 6\sqrt{3} \approx 10.3923$.
The exact algebraic ratios $\frac{\operatorname{Area}_6}{\operatorname{Area}_3} = \frac{3}{2}$ and $\frac{\operatorname{Area}_6}{\operatorname{Area}_4} = \frac{2\sqrt{3}}{3}$ (whose square is $\frac{12}{9} = \frac{4}{3} > 1$) prove without decimal approximation that the hexagon stores $50\%$ more honey than the triangle and $\frac{2\sqrt{3}}{3} \approx 15.47\%$ more honey than the square for the exact same wax perimeter!
Proceeding through Propositions 2–10 (Hultsch I pp. 312–336), Pappus completes the planar extremal proof:
Prop. 2: A circle of perimeter $P$ has area $\frac{P^2}{4\pi}$ strictly greater than any regular polygon of the same perimeter: circumscribing a similar regular polygon around the circle gives area $\frac{1}{2} P_{\text{circ}} R$, and since the circumscribed polygon’s perimeter strictly exceeds the circle’s circumference (Archimedes, On the Sphere and Cylinder I), scaling down to common perimeter $P$ shrinks the polygon’s apothem strictly below $R$.
Props. 4–6: Among triangles on the same base with equal sum of the remaining two sides, the isosceles triangle has the greatest area; consequently, among all $n$-gons of given perimeter, any maximum-area $n$-gon must be equilateral.
Props. 7–10: Similarly, among equilateral polygons of given perimeter and side count, the equiangular one encloses greater area than one that is not equiangular—completing the chain $\text{irregular } n\text{-gon} < \text{regular } n\text{-gon} < \text{regular } (n+1)\text{-gon} < \text{circle}$.
In the spatial second half of Book V (Props. 11–43, Hultsch I pp. 336–473), Pappus compares the sphere and regular polyhedra of equal surface area and preserves in Chapter 34 (Prop. 19, pp. 352–358) the **sole surviving ancient Greek enumeration of all thirteen Archimedean semi-regular solids*.*