§ 7. Extension of the Preceding Considerations. Lie’s Sphere Geometry

A Comparative Review of Recent Researches in Geometry — § 7 (Trans. M. W. Haskell, 1893, pp. 228–232)

With the theory of binary forms, the geometry of reciprocal radii, and line geometry, which in the foregoing pages appear co-ordinated and only distinguished by the number of variables, may be connected certain further developments, which shall now be explained. In the first place, these developments are intended to illustrate with new examples the idea that the group determining the treatment of given subjects can be extended indefinitely; but, in the second place, the intention was particularly to explain the relation to the views here set forth of certain considerations presented by Lie in a recent article (Math. Ann. 5, 1872, 145–256). The way by which we here arrive at Lie's sphere geometry differs in this respect from the one pursued by Lie, that he proceeds from the conceptions of line geometry, while we assume a smaller number of variables in our exposition. This will enable us to be in agreement with the usual geometric perception and to preserve the connection with what precedes. The investigation is independent of the number of variables, as Lie himself has already pointed out (Göttinger Nachrichten, 1871, Nos. 7, 22). It belongs to that great class of investigations concerned with the projective discussion of quadratic equations between any number of variables, — investigations upon which we have already touched several times, and which will repeatedly meet us again (see § 10, for instance).

I proceed from the connection established between the real plane and the sphere by stereographic projection. In § 5 we connected plane geometry with the geometry on a conic section by making the straight line in the plane correspond to the point-pair in which it meets the conic. Similarly we can establish a connection between space geometry and the geometry on the sphere, by letting every plane of space correspond to the circle in which it cuts the sphere. If then by stereographic projection we transfer the geometry on the sphere from the latter to the plane (every circle being thereby transformed into a circle), we have the following correspondence:

  • the space geometry whose element is the plane and whose group is formed of the linear transformations converting a sphere into itself, and

  • the plane geometry whose element is the circle and whose group is the group of geometric inversion.

The former geometry we will now generalize in two directions by substituting for its group a more comprehensive group. The resulting extension may then be immediately transferred to plane geometry by representation (Abbildung).

Instead of those linear transformations of space (regarded as made up of planes) which convert the sphere into itself, it readily suggests itself to select either the totality of the linear transformations of space, or the totality of those plane-transformations which leave the sphere unchanged [in a sense yet to be examined]; in the former case we dispense with the sphere, in the latter with the linear character of the transformations. The former generalization is intelligible without further explanation; we will therefore consider it first and follow out its importance for plane geometry. To the second case we shall return later, and shall then in the first place have to determine the most general transformation of that kind.

Linear space-transformations have the common property of converting pencils and sheaves of planes into like pencils and sheaves. Now, transferred to the sphere, the pencil of planes gives a pencil of circles, i.e., a system of $\infty^1$ circles with common intersections; the sheaf of planes gives a sheaf of circles, i.e., a system of $\infty^2$ circles perpendicular to a fixed circle (the circle whose plane is the polar plane of the point common to the planes of the given sheaf). Hence to linear space-transformations there correspond on the sphere, and furthermore in the plane, circle-transformations characterized by the property that they convert pencils and sheaves of circles into the same [1]. The plane geometry which employs the group of transformations thus obtained is the representation of ordinary projective space geometry. In this geometry the point cannot be used as element of the plane, for the points do not form a body (§ 5) for the chosen group of transformations; but circles shall be chosen as elements.

In the case of the second extension named, the first question to be settled is with regard to the nature of the group of transformations in question. The problem is, to find plane-transformations converting every [sheaf] of planes whose [vertex lies on] the sphere into a like [sheaf]. For brevity of expression, we will first consider the reciprocal problem and, moreover, go down a step in the number of dimensions; we will therefore look for point-transformations of the plane which convert every tangent to a given conic into a like tangent. To this end we regard the plane with its conic as the representation of a quadric surface projected on the plane from a point of space not in the surface in such a way that the conic in question represents the boundary curve. To the tangents to the conic correspond the generators of the surface, and the problem is reduced to that of finding the totality of the point-transformations of the surface into itself by which generators remain generators.

Now, the number of these transformations is, to be sure, $\infty^n$, where $n$ may have any value. For we only need to regard the point on the surface as intersection of the generators of the two systems, and to transform each system of lines into itself in any way whatever. But among these are in particular the linear transformations, and to these alone will we attend. For, if we had to do, not with a surface, but with an $n$-dimensional manifoldness represented by a quadratic equation, the linear transformations alone would remain, the rest would disappear [2].

These linear transformations of the surface into itself, transferred to the plane by projection (other than stereographic), give two-valued point-transformations, by which from every tangent to the boundary conic is produced, it is true, a tangent, but from every other straight line in general a conic having double contact with the boundary curve. This group of transformations will be conveniently characterized by basing a projective measurement upon the boundary conic. The transformations will then have the property of converting points whose distance apart is zero by this measurement, and also points whose distance from a given point is constant, into points having the same properties.

All these considerations may be extended to any number of variables, and can in particular be applied to the original inquiry, which had reference to the sphere and plane as elements. We can then give the result an especially perspicuous form, because the angle formed by two planes according to the projective measurement referred to a sphere is equal to the angle in the ordinary sense formed by the circles in which they intersect the sphere.

We thus obtain upon the sphere, and furthermore in the plane, a group of circle-transformations having the property that they convert circles which are tangent to each other (include a zero angle), and also circles making equal angles with another circle, into like circles. The group of these transformations contains on the sphere the linear transformations, in the plane the transformations of the group of geometric inversion [3].

The circle geometry based on this group is analogous to the sphere geometry which Lie has devised for space and which appears of particular importance for investigations on the curvature of surfaces. It includes the geometry of reciprocal radii in the same sense as the latter includes elementary geometry.

The circle- (sphere-) transformations thus obtained have, in particular, the property of converting circles (spheres) which touch each other into circles (spheres) having the same property. If we regard all curves (surfaces) as envelopes of circles (spheres), then it results from this fact that curves (surfaces) which touch each other will always be transformed into curves (surfaces) having the same property. The transformations in question belong, therefore, to the class of contact-transformations to be considered from a general standpoint further on, i.e., transformations under which the contact of point-configurations is an invariant relation. The first circle-transformations mentioned in the present section, which find their parallel in corresponding sphere-transformations, are not contact-transformations.

While these two kinds of generalization have here been applied only to the geometry of reciprocal radii, they nevertheless hold in a similar way for line geometry and in general for the projective investigation of a manifoldness defined by a quadratic equation, as we have already indicated, but shall not develop further in this connection.


Footnotes (1893 Edition)