§ 19: Parallelograms and Triangles Having Equal Bases and Equal Altitudes¶
David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)
The well known reasoning of Euclid, illustrated by the accompanying figure, furnishes a proof for the following theorem:
Theorem 25. Two parallelograms having equal bases and equal altitudes are also of equal content.
We have also the following well known proposition:
Theorem 26. Any triangle $ABC$ is always of equal area to a certain parallelogram having an equal base and an altitude half as great as that of the triangle.
Proof. Bisect $AC$ in $D$ and $BC$ in $E$, and extend the line $DE$ to $F$, making $EF$ equal to $DE$. Then, the triangles $DEC$ and $FBE$ are congruent to each other, and, consequently, the triangle $ABC$ and the parallelogram $ABFD$ are of equal area.
From theorems 25 and 26, we have at once, by aid of theorem 24, the following proposition.
Theorem 27. Two triangles having equal bases and equal altitudes have also equal content.
It is usual to show that two triangles having equal bases and equal altitudes are always of equal area. It is to be remarked, however, that this demonstration cannot be made without the aid of the axiom of Archimedes. In fact, we may easily construct in our non-archimedean geometry (see § 12, p. 34) two triangles so that they shall have equal bases and equal altitudes and, consequently, by theorem 27, must be of equal content, but which are not, however, of equal area. As such an example, we may take the two triangles $ABC$ and $ABD$ having each the base $AB=1$ and the altitude $1$, where the vertex of the first triangle is situated perpendicularly above $A$, and in the second triangle the foot $F$ of the perpendicular let fall from the vertex $D$ upon the base is so situated that $AF=t$. The remaining propositions of elementary geometry concerning the equal content of polygons, and in particular the pythagorean theorem, are all simple consequences of the theorems which we have already given. In the further development of the theory of area, we meet, however, with an essential difficulty. In fact, the discussion so far leaves it still in doubt whether all polygons are not, perhaps, of equal content. In this case, all of the propositions which we have given would be devoid of meaning and hence of no value. Furthermore, the more general question also arises as to whether two rectangles of equal content and having one side in common, do not also have their other sides congruent; that is to say, whether a rectangle is not definitely determined by means of a side and its area. As a closer investigation shows, in order to answer this question, we need to make use of the converse of theorem 27. This may be stated as follows:
Theorem 28. If two triangles have equal content and equal bases, they have also equal altitudes.
This fundamental theorem is to be found in the first book of Euclid’s Elements as proposition 39. In the demonstration of this theorem, however, Euclid appeals to the general proposition relating to magnitudes: “$K \alpha \grave{\iota} \ \tau \grave{o} \ \check{o} \lambda o \upsilon \ \tau o \hat{\nu} \ \mu \acute{\epsilon} \rho o \upsilon \varsigma \ \mu \epsilon \hat{\iota} \zeta \acute{o} \nu \ \grave{\epsilon} \sigma \tau \iota \nu$”—a method of procedure which amounts to the same thing as introducing a new geometrical axiom concerning areas.
It is now possible to establish the above theorem and hence the theory of areas in the manner we have proposed, that is to say, with the help of the plane axioms and without making use of the axiom of Archimedes. In order to show this, it is necessary to introduce the idea of the measure of area.