Chapter IV: The Theory of Plane Areas

Kapitel IV: Die Lehre von den Flächeninhalten in der Ebene — David Hilbert (1899 / 1902) — §§ 18–21

Building directly upon Chapter III’s non-Archimedean Streckenrechnung, Chapter IV reconstructs Euclid’s Book I (I.35–45) theory of polygonal area in the plane solely from planar Axioms `I 1–2, II–IV` without Continuity (`V`):

  • § 18 — Equidecomposability vs. Equicomplementability (Theorem 24): Introduces the decisive distinction between two polygons being flächengleich (1899 term; renamed zerlegungsgleich in later editions; Townsend: “equal by addition” / equidecomposable into pairwise congruent triangles) versus inhaltsgleich (Townsend: “of equal content” / equicomplementable by adjoining equidecomposable pieces). Proves transitivity of both relations by common subdivision (Theorem 24).

  • § 19 — Parallelograms and Triangles (Theorems 25–28): Reproduces Euclid’s I.35–38 trapezoid-subtraction argument to prove that parallelograms and triangles on equal bases with equal altitudes are always inhaltsgleich (Theorems 25–27), but exhibits a dramatic counterexample in $\Omega(t)$ (§ 12): two triangles of base $1$ and altitude $1$ whose apex projection is offset by the non-Archimedean element $t$ are inhaltsgleich yet cannot be dissected into congruent triangles (not flächengleich)! Formulates the converse (Theorem 28, Euclid I.39) and notes that Euclid relied on Common Notion 5 („Καὶ τὸ ὅλον τοῦ μέρους μεῖζόν ἐστιν“) as an unproved area axiom.

  • § 20 — Measure of Area (*Flächenmass*, Theorem 29): Defines the area measure $F(\Delta) = \tfrac{1}{2} a h_a = \tfrac{1}{2} b h_b$ in the segment field via Theorem 22, proves invariance of $F(\Delta)$ under arbitrary simplicial subdivision by reducing any triangulation to chains of transversal splits (Theorem 29), and deduces that inhaltsgleich polygons have equal area measure—immediately proving Theorem 28.

  • § 21 — Converse Equivalence and De Zolt’s Postulate (Theorems 30–31): Proves conversely that any two polygons with equal segment-valued area measure are inhaltsgleich (Theorem 30), and deduces Antonio De Zolt’s postulate / Euclid C.N. 5 (Theorem 31): if a rectangle is dissected into triangles and even a single triangle is omitted, the remaining triangles can never refill the rectangle!

Sections

§ 18: Equal Area and Equal Content of Polygons

We shall base the investigations of the present chapter upon the same axioms as were made use of in the last chapter, §§ 13–17, namely, upon the plane axioms of all the groups, with the single exception of the axiom of Archimedes. This involves then the axioms I, 1–2 and II–IV.

E A D B C B' C'

§ 19: Parallelograms and Triangles Having Equal Bases and Equal Altitudes

The well known reasoning of Euclid, illustrated by the accompanying figure, furnishes a proof for the following theorem: