§ 18: Equal Area and Equal Content of Polygons¶
David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)
We shall base the investigations of the present chapter upon the same axioms as were made use of in the last chapter, §§ 13–17, namely, upon the plane axioms of all the groups, with the single exception of the axiom of Archimedes. This involves then the axioms I, 1–2 and II–IV.
The theory of proportion as developed in §§ 13–17 together with the algebra of segments introduced in the same chapter, puts us now in a position to establish Euclid’s theory of areas by means of the axioms already mentioned; that is to say, for the plane geometry, and that independently of the axiom of Archimedes.
Since, by the development given in the last chapter, pp. 37–56, the theory of proportion was made to depend essentially upon Pascal’s theorem (theorem 21), the same may then be said here of the theory of areas. This manner of establishing the theory of areas seems to me a very remarkable application of Pascal’s theorem to elementary geometry.
If we join two points of a polygon $P$ by any arbitrary broken line lying entirely within the polygon, we shall obtain two new polygons $P_1$ and $P_2$ whose interior points all lie within $P$. We say that $P$ is decomposed into $P_1$ and $P_2$, or that the polygon $P$ is composed of $P_1$ and $P_2$.
Definition. Two polygons are said to be of equal area when they can be decomposed into a finite number of triangles which are respectively congruent to one another in pairs.
Definition. Two polygons are said to be of equal content when it is possible, by the addition of other polygons having equal area, to obtain two resulting polygons having equal area.
From these definitions, it follows at once that by combining polygons having equal area, we obtain as a result polygons having equal area. However, if from polygons having equal area we take polygons having equal area, we obtain polygons which are of equal content.
Furthermore, we have the following propositions:
Theorem 24. If each of two polygons $P_1$ and $P_2$ is of equal area to a third polygon $P_3$ then $P_1$ and $P_2$ are themselves of equal area. If each of two polygons is of equal content to a third, then they are themselves of equal content.
Proof. By hypothesis, we can so decompose each of the polygons $P_1$ and $P_2$ into such a system of triangles that any triangle of either of these systems will be congruent to the corresponding triangle of a system into which $P_3$ may be decomposed. If we consider simultaneously the two decompositions of $P_3$ we see that, in general, each triangle of the one decomposition is broken up into polygons by the segments which belong to the other decomposition. Let ms add to these segments a sufficient number of others to reduce each of these polygons to triangles, and apply the two resulting methods of decompositions to $P_1$ and $P_2$, thus breaking them up into corresponding triangles. Then, evidently the two polygons $P_1$ and $P_2$ are each decomposed into the same number of triangles, which are respectively congruent by pairs. Consequently, the two polygons are, by definition, of equal area.
The proof of the second part of the theorem follows without difficulty.
We define, in the usual manner, the terms: rectangle, base and height of a parallelogram, base and height of a triangle.
% required for correct placement of Figures 30 and 31