Props. III.20–III.23: Stereometric Divisions & Hero’s Cube-Root Algorithm (∛100 ≈ 4 9/14)

f. Schöne 174 · p. 174

In the final four propositions of the Metrica, Hero ascends from two-dimensional area divisions (governed by duplicate ratios and square roots) to three-dimensional solid divisions (governed by triplicate ratios [XII.12] and cube roots):

  • Proposition III.20 — Dividing a Pyramid or Cone Parallel to Its Base & Extracting :math:`sqrt[3]{100}` (Schöne pp. 172–178; fols. 105v–106v): To cut a pyramid (or cone) of slant edge \(5\) into ratio \(4 : 1\) from the apex (\(\frac{4}{5}\) upper pyramid to \(\frac{1}{5}\) lower frustum), similar pyramids stand in the triplicate ratio of their homologous edges:

    \[\frac{x^3}{5^3} = \frac{4}{5} \qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad x^3 = \frac{4}{5} \times 125 = 100.\]

    How can one extract the cube root of 100 (\(\sqrt[3]{100}\)), the sole surviving cube-root algorithm in all of Greek mathematical literature? Hero gives his celebrated weighted secant/error-interpolation rule (Schöne p. 178):

    1. Take the nearest integer cubes above and below \(N = 100\): \(5^3 = 125\) (root \(u = 5\)) and \(4^3 = 64\) (root \(\ell = 4\)).

    2. Compute the upper excess \(e_u = 125 - 100 = 25\) and the lower deficit \(e_\ell = 100 - 64 = 36\).

    3. Multiply the upper root by the lower deficit (\(u \cdot e_\ell = 5 \times 36 = 180\)), and the lower root by the upper excess (or in Schöne’s text \(\sqrt{100 \dots}\) / \(4 \times 25\)—specifically \(90 + \dots\) or \(180 / (180 + 100)\)): adding \(180\) and \(100\) (\(= 280\)) and dividing \(180\) by \(280\) gives \(\frac{9}{14}\)!

    4. Add \(\frac{9}{14}\) to the lower root \(4\):

      \[x \approx 4 + \frac{9}{14} = \frac{65}{14} \approx 4.642857\dots \qquad \text{(exact } \sqrt[3]{100} \approx 4.6415888\dots\text{)},\]

      achieving relative accuracy of :math:`0.027%` (\((\frac{65}{14})^3 = \frac{274{,}625}{2744} \approx 100.082\)) in a single rational step!

  • Propositions III.21–III.22 (Dividing a Conical or Pyramidal Frustum Parallel to Its Bases, Schöne pp. 178–182): Extending the frustum to its virtual apex reduces the frustum cut to \(x^3 = \frac{n a^3 + m b^3}{m + n}\), solved immediately via the cube-root method of Prop. III.20.

  • Proposition III.23 (Dividing a Sphere in a Given Ratio by a Plane, Schöne pp. 182–184; fol. 107v): Concluding the entire three-book treatise, Hero poses the famous cubic problem of Archimedes' Sphere and Cylinder II.4—to cut a sphere by a plane so that its segments have a given ratio \(m : n\)—and cites Dionysodorus's conic-section solution via the intersection of a parabola and a rectangular hyperbola!