Props. II.16–II.20: Five Platonic Solids & Irregular Hydrostatic Displacement

f. Schöne 132 · p. 132

Propositions II.16–II.19 — Volumes of the Five Regular Solids (Schöne pp. 132–138; fols. 97r–99r):

Turning to the five cosmic regular polyhedra of Plato, Theaetetus, and Euclid ([XIII.13]–[XIII.17]), Hero decomposes the octahedron into two square pyramids and the icosahedron and dodecahedron into \(20\) triangular and \(12\) pentagonal pyramids meeting at the center of the circumscribed/inscribed sphere:

Exact Symbolic Volumes of the Five Platonic Solids (Edge \(a\))

Prop.

Regular Polyhedron

Faces

Exact Volume \(V(a)\) in \(\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, \phi)\)

Unit

Cube (Κύβος)

\(6\) squares

\(a^3\) (foundational stereometric unit)

II.16

Regular Tetrahedron (Πυραμίς)

\(4\) equilateral \(\triangle\)

\(\frac{\sqrt{2}}{12} a^3\) (altitude \(h = \sqrt{\frac{2}{3}} a\) )

II.17

Regular Octahedron (Ὀκτάεδρον)

\(8\) equilateral \(\triangle\)

\(\frac{\sqrt{2}}{3} a^3\) (two square pyramids of height \(\frac{a}{\sqrt{2}}\) )

II.18

Regular Icosahedron (Εἰκοσάεδρον)

\(20\) equilateral \(\triangle\)

\(\frac{5(3 + \sqrt{5})}{12} a^3 = \frac{5\phi^2}{6} a^3\) (inradius via \(\mathbb{Q}(\phi)\) )

II.19

Regular Dodecahedron (Δωδεκάεδρον)

\(12\) regular pentagons

\(\frac{15 + 7\sqrt{5}}{4} a^3 = \frac{5\phi^3}{2(2-\phi)} a^3\) (12 pentagonal pyramids)

Notice the exact golden-ratio duality between II.18 and II.19: both depend directly upon the extreme-and-mean-ratio geometry established in Proposition I.18!

f. Schöne 138 · p. 138
  • Proposition II.20 (Measuring Any Irregular Solid Body, Schöne pp. 138–140; fols. 99r–99v): Book II closes with an unforgettable synthesis of physics and geometry. How can one measure an irregular sculpted statue, rough boulder, or vessel (ἀκανόνιστον σῶμα) bounded by no geometric formula? Hero gives two exact operational methods:

    1. Hydrostatic Immersion (*Archimedes’ Bath*): Place a watertight rectangular parallelepiped tank horizontally, fill it with water, submerge the irregular solid completely, and measure the vertical rise (or displaced overflow) of the rectangular prism of water; its length \(\times\) breadth \(\times\) depth gives the irregular solid’s exact volume in cubic units!

    2. Plastic Clay/Wax Encasement: If the body is too monumental or immovable to immerse, pack wax or potter’s clay (κηρὸς ἢ πηλός) around it and plane the exterior flat with straightedges into a right-angled rectangular parallelepiped; measure that parallelepiped, strip off the clay and mold the clay alone into a smaller rectangular brick, and subtract the brick’s volume from the whole!