DISTINCTIO VIII — SUBTILITATES GEOMETRICAE & FLOS (1225)

Geometrical Subtleties of the Pentagon and Decagon, Al-Jabr Quartic, and the Flos Imperial Cubic

Source Text: fibonacci:pg-8, fibonacci:flos (Boncompagni Vol. II, pp. 207–234 · fol. 134r–148v & Flos) · Latin (1220 / Boncompagni 1862) · Summary · GEOMETOR Notes


Distinctio VIII — Subtilitates Geometricae: Pentagon, Decagon & Al-Jabr

Latin Locus: Distinctio VIII — De Subtilitatibus Geometricis (pp. 207–226) · Commentary: Notes on Abū Kāmil’s Quartic & Euclid XIII.10

Here begins the Eighth Distinction, on certain geometrical subtleties (de quibusdam subtilitatibus geometricis): to find the chords and sides of the regular decagon and pentagon inscribed in a circle of rational diameter $d = 10$, both by geometrical proof and by the rule of algebra (secundum modum algebrae et almuchabalae).
Distinctio VIII — Regular Pentagon & Decagon in Circle of Diameter 10 ( I A ): x**2 + y**2 - 25 = 0 ( H D ): y**2 + (x - 5/2)**2 - 125/4 = 0 [ I K ]: y = 0 / I D /: length = 5 / H D /: length = 5*sqrt(5)/2 / I K /: length = -5/2 + 5*sqrt(5)/2 / D K /: length = 5*sqrt(10 - 2*sqrt(5))/2 / D Q1 /: length = 10*sqrt(-600*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) - 450*sqrt(6)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5)) - 150*sqrt(30)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5)) - 600*sqrt(5) - 60*sqrt(5)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 600*sqrt(6)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5400)/(sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*(sqrt(15)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5*sqrt(3)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 30*sqrt(2))) / Q1 P1 /: length = 10*sqrt(-600*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) - 450*sqrt(6)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5)) - 150*sqrt(30)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5)) - 600*sqrt(5) - 60*sqrt(5)*sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 600*sqrt(6)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5400)/(sqrt(5 - sqrt(5))*(sqrt(15)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5*sqrt(3)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 30*sqrt(2))) A = (5, 0) C = (-5, 0) I = (0, 0) D = (0, 5) H = (5/2, 0) P1 = (5*sqrt(2)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/4, -5/4 + 5*sqrt(5)/4) P4 = (-5*sqrt(2)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/4, -5/4 + 5*sqrt(5)/4) P2 = (-5*sqrt(2)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/8 + 5*sqrt(10)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/8, -5*sqrt(5)/4 - 5/4) P3 = (-5*sqrt(10)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/8 + 5*sqrt(2)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5)/8, -5*sqrt(5)/4 - 5/4) K = (5/2 - 5*sqrt(5)/2, 0) Q1 = ((-75*sqrt(15) + 75*sqrt(2)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 375*sqrt(3))/(sqrt(15 - 3*sqrt(5))*(sqrt(15)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5*sqrt(3)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 30*sqrt(2))), (75*sqrt(5) + 225 + 75*sqrt(6)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5))/(sqrt(15 - 3*sqrt(5))*(sqrt(15)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 5*sqrt(3)*sqrt(sqrt(5) + 5) + 30*sqrt(2)))) A C I D H P1 P4 P2 P3 K Q1
Circle ( I A ) of diameter CA = 10 (center I, radius ID = 5, midpoint H = 5/2): arc ( H D ) of radius / H D / = sqrt(31 1/4) cuts [ I K ] at K, giving decagon side / I K / = / D Q1 / = sqrt(31 1/4) - 2 1/2 and pentagon side / D K / = sqrt(62 1/2 - sqrt(781 1/4)) inscribing < D P1 P2 P3 P4 >.
  1. Euclidean Construction in Circle Diameter $10$ ([XIII. 9–10]): In circle (IA) of diameter $CA = 10$ through C, center I, and A, erect perpendicular radius ID $= 5$ to apex D, and bisect $IC$ at H ($IH = 2\frac{1}{2}$). Then hypotenuse HD has square $25 + 6\frac{1}{4} = 31\frac{1}{4}$. Turning circle (HD) onto the diameter at K along IK divides radius $IA = 5$ (the inscribed hexagon side) in extreme and mean ratio, yielding the decagon side IK equal to chord DQ1 (an apotome):

    $$s_{10} = IK = \sqrt{31\frac{1}{4}} - 2\frac{1}{2} = \frac{5(\sqrt{5} - 1)}{2}.$$

    By Euclid’s theorem that the square on the pentagon side equals the sum of the squares on the hexagon and decagon sides [XIII. 10], hypotenuse DK is the exact side of the regular pentagon DP1P2P3P4 (with vertices P1, P2, P3, P4):

    $$s_5^2 = ID^2 + IK^2 = 25 + \left(37\frac{1}{2} - \sqrt{781\frac{1}{4}}\right) = 62\frac{1}{2} - \sqrt{781\frac{1}{4}}, \qquad s_5 = \frac{5\sqrt{10 - 2\sqrt{5}}}{2}.$$

  2. Algebraic Derivation via *Res*, *Census* & *Census Census* (ptolemy:almagest): Following al-Khwārizmī and Abū Kāmil, let the unknown pentagon side be one thing (res $= x$), so its square is one census ($x^2$) and its fourth power is census census ($x^4$). Combining Ptolemy’s cyclic-quadrilateral theorem [VI. D] with diameter $d = 10$ produces the biquadratic equation:

    $$x^4 + 3{,}125 = 125\,x^2.$$

    Completing the square in census ($x^2 = 62\frac{1}{2} - \sqrt{3{,}906\frac{1}{4} - 3{,}125} = 62\frac{1}{2} - \sqrt{781\frac{1}{4}}$) recovers the identical Euclid X minor irrational!


f. boncompagni_1862_vol2_practica_geometriae:0234 · p. 227–234

Flos (1225) — The Imperial Cubic & Book X Irrationals

Latin Locus: Flos super Solutionibus Quarundam Questionum (pp. 227–234) · Commentary: Notes on the Flos Cubic & Congruum

Five years after Practica Geometriae, at the Pisan court of Emperor Frederick II, Master John of Palermo proposed two celebrated challenges preserved in Leonardo’s Flos (fibonacci:flos, dedicated to Cardinal Raniero Capocci):

  1. The Congruum of Five (Liber Quadratorum & Flos): Find a rational square $x^2$ which, increased or diminished by $5$, remains a rational square ($x^2 \pm 5 = \square$). Scaling by $12^2 = 144$ (since $5 \times 144 = 720$ is a congruum arising from $m = 5, n = 4$: $4mn(m^2 - n^2) = 720$), Leonardo exhibits $31^2 + 720 = 41^2$ and $41^2 + 720 = 49^2$, whence $x = 3\frac{5}{12} = \frac{41}{12}$:

    $$\left(\frac{41}{12}\right)^2 - 5 = \left(\frac{31}{12}\right)^2, \qquad \left(\frac{41}{12}\right)^2 + 5 = \left(\frac{49}{12}\right)^2.$$

  2. The Irreducible Cubic Equation: Find a line $x$ such that a cube plus two squares and ten roots equals twenty:

    $$x^3 + 2x^2 + 10x = 20.$$

    Testing every species of rational fraction and every quadratic irrational classified in Euclid’s Book X (binomiale, recisum, medial, minor, major), Leonardo proves rigorously that $x$ cannot be expressed by any square-root tower of Book X, and then exhibits its astonishing six-place sexagesimal root:

    $$x \approx 1^{\circ}\ 22'\ 7''\ 42'''\ 33''''\ 4'''''\ 40'''''' = \frac{1{,}596{,}577{,}777}{1{,}166{,}400{,}000} \approx 1.36880810785322\dots$$

    whose error from the true real root $1.36880810782137\dots$ is less than $3.2 \times 10^{-11}$!