Definitions (Ὅροι) of Euclid’s Data¶
Interactive diagram key (Menge pp. 2–4): Panel 1 illustrates Magnitude ([Data Def. 1]), constructing segment CD equal to given AB. Panel 2 illustrates Species ([Data Def. 3]), pairing homothetic triangles EFG and HKL with equal angles ∠FEG and ∠KHL and given side ratios ($2:3$). Panel 3 illustrates Position ([Data Def. 4], [Data Def. 6]), where fixed circle (O, OM) with centre O and radius OM meets fixed straight line PQ at uniquely determined points M and N.
Overview of the Fifteen Definitions (Menge pp. 2–4)¶
Menge ID |
Simson ID |
Mode of Givenness |
Functional Predicate |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Def. I |
Magnitude (μεγέθει) |
|
||
Def. II |
Ratio (λόγῳ) |
|
||
Def. III |
Species (εἴδει) |
|
||
Def. IV (cf. Def. A) |
Position (θέσει) |
|
||
Def. V |
Circle in Magnitude |
|
||
Def. VI |
Circle in Position & Magnitude |
|
||
Def. VII |
Circular Segment in Magnitude |
|
||
Def. VIII |
Circular Segment in Position & Magnitude |
|
||
Def. IX |
Affine Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον) |
|
||
Def. X |
Affine Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον) |
|
||
Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII) |
Affine-Ratio Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ) |
|
||
Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII) |
Affine-Ratio Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ) |
|
||
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Directed Ordinate [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
||
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Erected Line [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
||
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Parallel to Position [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
2. Simson’s Regular-Heptagon Critique of Definition 4 (Position)¶
[Data Def. 4] defines points, lines, and angles as given in position when they “always occupy the same place” (ἃ τὸν αὐτὸν ἀεὶ τόπον ἐπέχει). In his critical note on Def. IV (p. 455), Simson observed that Euclid’s wording captures Apollonius's τεταγμένον (uniquely determined in nature) while omitting πόριμον (constructible by elementary means): if $\triangle ABC$ is given in position, a ray $BD$ cutting off $\angle DBC = \frac{1}{7} \angle ABC$ occupies an invariant, unique place, yet cannot be constructed by straightedge and compass (since angle septisection / the regular heptagon requires a cubic neusis or conic intersection, outside the quadratic closure of the Elements). Simson therefore appended “and which are either actually exhibited, or can be found”—confirming in detail Marinus's diagnosis in § 15 that givenness requires procurability (πόριμον), not mere uniqueness (τεταγμένον).
3. Affine-Ratio Idiom in Definitions 11–12 (Δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ)¶
[Data Def. 11] and [Data Def. 12] introduce Euclid’s remarkably compact Greek idiom δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ (“greater [or less] by a given magnitude than in ratio”):
where offset $D$ is given in magnitude and slope $k$ is given in ratio. This turns 1D affine-linear transformations into a single syntactic predicate closed under composition (D.19) and Gaussian elimination (D.17–D.18). Simson (p. 456) omitted Defs. 11–12 only because literal English sounded obscure, expanding the phrase verbally as “the excess of one magnitude above a given magnitude has a given ratio to the other” across his Props. XIV–XXVII.
4. Manuscript Authority & Bracketing of Definitions 13–15¶
In the ninth-century non-Theonine Vatican archetype Vat. gr. 190 (Codex P) collated by Heinrich Menge (1896, p. 4), Definitions 1–12 form the authentic Euclidean core, whereas [Data Def. 13] (κατηγμένη), [Data Def. 14] (ἀνηγμένη), and [Data Def. 15] (παρὰ θέσει) are enclosed in editorial brackets [...] as post-Euclidean scholia imported from Alexandrian locus and conic terminology (their terms never appear in the proofs of D.28–D.30, where Euclid writes out the full geometric descriptions). Simson (p. 456) had already rejected all three on internal mathematical grounds.