Critical Notes — Refutation of Kant’s Theory of Space and Spatial Intuition

Primary Text: Read Verbatim Section Track · Summary: Executive Summary Track

Textual & Epistemological Commentary

The Three-Cornered Debate: Kant, Russell, and Hoenen

Russell (§434) and Hoenen (De Noetica Geometriae, Caput I–II & IV) both reject Kant’s subjective a priori form of sensibility, yet diverge sharply on what replaces it: Russell banishes intuition completely from pure mathematics into hypothetico-deductive logicism, whereas Hoenen rehabilitates objective Aristotelian-Thomistic intellective intuition abstracted from sensory phantasms (resolutio ad sensum) to ground the truth of first principles.