Chapter LII: Kant’s Theory of Space

Part VI — Space (§§ 432–436, pp. 454–461)

Concluding Part VI, Chapter LII (Kant’s Theory of Space, §§432–436, pp. 454–461) delivers Russell’s definitive logicist critique of Immanuel Kant’s Transcendental Aesthetic and First/Second Mathematical Antinomies. Russell shows that Cantor’s transfinite continuum dissolves Kant’s antinomies (§433), that modern relational logic Deduces all pure geometry without spatial construction in intuition (§434), that incongruent counterparts (left and right hands) arise purely from three-dimensional ordinal sense (§435), and summarizes the complete reduction of pure geometry to the logic of serial relations (§436).

Refutation of Kant’s Theory of Space and Spatial Intuition

432. In the present chapter I do not propose to undertake a minute or textual examination of Kant’s opinions; this has been done elsewhere, and notably in Vaihinger’s monumental commentary, so well that it need not be done over again here. It is only the broad outlines of the Kantian doctrine that I wish to discuss. This doctrine, more or less modified, has held the field for over a century, and has won a nearly universal acceptance. As my views are, on almost every point of mathematical theory, diametrically opposed to those of Kant, it becomes necessary explicitly to defend the opinions in which I differ from him . In this I shall pay special attention to what Kant calls the transcendental arguments, i.e. those derived from the nature of mathematics.