Chapter LI: Logical Arguments Against Points¶
Part VI — Space (§§ 423–431, pp. 445–453)
Chapter LI (Logical Arguments Against Points, §§423–431, pp. 445–453) confronts the classical metaphysical controversy between absolute (substantival) and relational theories of space. Reversing the relational conclusion of his 1897 Essay (Ch. IV), Russell dissects Lotze’s monadistic critique of empty space (§§424–428) and Leibniz’s identity of indiscernibles (§429), arguing that relationalism covertly presupposes irreducible asymmetric spatial relations whose terms can only be absolute, unextended points differing immediately without qualitative adjectives.
Logical Arguments Against Points and Vindication of Absolute Position
423. It has been an almost universal opinion among philosophers, ever since the time of Leibniz, that a space composed of points is logically impossible. It is maintained that the spatial relations with which we have been concerned do not hold between spatial points, which essentially and timelessly have the relations which they do have, but between material points, which are capable of motion, i.e. of a change in their spatial relations. This is called the theory of relative position, whereas the theory of spatial points is called the theory of absolute position. Those who advocate relative position usually also maintain that matter and spatial relations, on account of certain contradictions supposed to be found in them, are not real, but belong only to the world of appearance. This is, however, a further point, which need not be explicitly discussed in what follows. Apart from this point, the issue between the absolute and relative theories may be stated as follows: The absolute theory holds that there are true propositions in which spatial relations are asserted to hold timelessly between certain terms, which may be called spatial points; the relational theory holds that every true proposition asserting a spatial relation involves a time at which this relation holds between its terms, so that the simplest spatial propositions assert triangular relations of a time and two terms, which may be called material points.