Chapter XLVI: Descriptive Geometry

Part VI — Space (§§ 374–387, pp. 393–403)

Chapter XLVI (Descriptive Geometry, §§374–387, pp. 393–403) examines spaces in which two points determine an open serial line rather than a closed projective circuit—the common ordinal substrate of Euclidean and hyperbolic geometry prior to congruence. Synthesizing Moritz Pasch (1882) and Giuseppe Peano (1889/1894), Russell axiomatizes betweenness, proves planar intersection properties via Pasch’s transversal axiom (§380), and demonstrates how adjoining ideal points, lines, and planes defined as logical classes (sheaves of lines) embeds every descriptive three-space into a projective space (§§383–387).

Pasch, Peano, and the Serial Definition of Betweenness

374. The subject which I have called descriptive Geometry is not, as a rule, sharply distinguished from projective Geometry. These two terms, and the term “Geometry of Position,” are commonly used as synonyms. But it seems improper to include in projective Geometry any property which is not unaltered by projection, and it is by the introduction of one such property that I wish to define the subject of the present chapter. We have seen that, in projective space, three points on a line are not such that a definite one of them is between the other two. The simplest possible proposition involving between, in projective Geometry, requires four points, and is as follows: “If a, b, c be distinct collinear points, and d is on ac, but does not belong to the segment (abc), nor yet coincide with a or c, then, with regard to the order abc, c is between b and d.” When we reflect that the definition of the segment (abc) involves the quadrilateral construction—which demands, for its proof, a point outside its own plane, and four pairs of triangles in perspective—we shall admit that the projective method of generating order is somewhat complicated. But at any rate the ordinal propositions which result are unaltered by projection. The elementary sense of between, on the contrary, which is to be introduced in the present chapter, is in general not unaltered by projection .

Ideal Points, Lines, Planes, and Projective Completion

381. Having successfully defined the plane, we can now advance to solid Geometry. For this we need, to begin with, the axiom: Given any plane, there is at least one point outside the plane. We can then define a tetrahedron exactly as we defined a triangle. But in order to know that two planes, which have a point in common, have a line in common, we need a new axiom, which shows that the space we are dealing with has three dimensions. In projective space, this axiom was simply that a line and a plane always have at least one point in common. But here, no such simple axiom holds. The following is given by Peano (loc. cit. p. 74): If p be a plane, and a a point not on p, and b a point of $a'$p (i.e. a point such that the segment ab contains a point of p, or, in common language, a point on the other side of the plane from a), then if x be any point, either x lies on the plane, or the segment ax contains a point of the plane, or else the segment bx contains a point of the plane. By adding to this, finally, an axiom of continuity, we have all the apparatus of three-dimensional descriptive Geometry .