Chapter XLV: Projective Geometry

Part VI — Space (§§ 361–373, pp. 381–392)

Chapter XLV (Projective Geometry, §§361–373, pp. 381–392) establishes the pure qualitative architecture of projective three-space without appeal to betweenness, segments, or metrical distance. Following Karl Georg Christian von Staudt (1847) and Mario Pieri (1898), Russell defines lines and planes as classes of points determined by symmetric incidence relations, constructs harmonic ranges via the complete quadrilateral (§365), derives cyclic order via Vailati’s separation of couples and involutions (§§366–367), assigns rational and real projective coordinates through Möbius nets (§§368–371), and culminates in projective duality (§373).

Pieri’s Projective Postulates, Lines, and Involutions

361. The foundations of Geometry have been subjected, in recent times, to a threefold scrutiny. First came the work of the non-Euclideans, which showed that various axioms, long known to be sufficient for certain results, were also necessary, i.e. that results inconsistent with the usual results but consistent with each other followed from the denial of those axioms. Next came the work of Dedekind and Cantor on the nature of continuity, which showed the necessity of investigating carefully the prerequisites of analytical Geometry. Lastly, a great change has been introduced by the Italian work on closed series, mentioned in Part IV, in virtue of which we are able, given a certain type of relation between four points of a line, to introduce an order of all the points of a line. The work of the non-Euclideans has, by this time, produced probably almost all the modifications that it is likely to produce in the foundations, while the work of Dedekind and Cantor only becomes relevant at a fairly advanced stage of Geometry. The work on closed series, on the contrary, being very recent, has not yet been universally recognized, although, as we shall see in the present chapter, it has enormously increased the range of pure projective Geometry.

Möbius Nets, Projective Order, and Duality

367. Given any three different points a, b, c on a line, consider the class of points x such that a and c, b and x are each harmonic conjugates with respect to some pair of points y, $y'$—in other words, a and c, b and x are pairs in an involution whose double points are y, $y'$. Here y, $y'$ are supposed variable: that is, if any such points can be found, x is to belong to the class considered. This class contains the point b, but not a or c. Let us call it the segment (abc). Let us denote the relation of b to x (a and c being fixed) by bQ$_{ac}$x. Then $Q_{ac}$ is symmetrical, and also bQ$_{ac}$x implies aQ$_{bx}$c. We have here a relation of four points, from which, as we saw in Part IV, Chapter xxiv, an order will result if certain further axioms are fulfilled. Three such axioms are required, and are given by Pieri as follows.