Chapter 13 · Summary

The Menelaus Spherical Calculus & Solar Declination

  1. Planar Menelaus Sector Lemma: Drawing auxiliary parallel $EH \parallel \Gamma\Delta$ demonstrates the compound ratios:

    $$\frac{\Gamma A}{AE} = \frac{\Gamma\Delta}{\Delta Z}\cdot\frac{ZB}{BE} \qquad\text{(:term:`κατὰ σύνθεσιν <kata-synthesin>`)}.$$

    $$\frac{\Gamma E}{EA} = \frac{\Gamma Z}{Z\Delta}\cdot\frac{\Delta B}{BA} \qquad\text{(:term:`κατὰ διαίρεσιν <kata-diairesin>`)}.$$

  2. 3D Central Projection onto the Sphere: Projecting great-circle intersections from the sphere center $H$ onto the plane of $\triangle A\Gamma\Delta$ maps great circle $BZE$ to the straight line $\Theta K\Lambda$ in space (Eucl. XI.3), establishing the spherical Menelaus theorem for double-arc chords.

  3. The Solar Declination Law (*Almagest* I.14): Specializing Spherical Menelaus to the celestial quadrant between celestial equator and ecliptic reduces the compound ratio to the exact chord equivalent of the modern spherical sine law $\sin\delta = \sin\varepsilon \sin\lambda$:

    $$\operatorname{crd}(2\delta) = \frac{\operatorname{crd}(2\varepsilon)\cdot\operatorname{crd}(2\lambda)}{120}.$$

Exact Symbolic vs. Heiberg (1898) Declination Check

Solar Longitude $\lambda$

$\operatorname{crd}(2\lambda)$

$\operatorname{crd}(2\delta)$

Computed $\delta(\lambda)$

Heiberg (1898, p. 78)

$30^\circ$ (Taurus / 1 sign)

60;0,0

24;15,57

11;40,0°

11° 40'

$60^\circ$ (Gemini / 2 signs)

103;55,23

42;1,48

20;30,9°

20° 30' 9''

$90^\circ$ (Solstice)

120;0,0

48;31,55

23;51,20°

23° 51' 20''