Prop. I.29: Parallel Lines & Proclus’s Attempted Proof of Postulate 5 — GEOMETOR Commentary & Concordance Notes¶
GEOMETOR Philosophical & Mathematical Commentary¶
Proclus’s commentary on Prop. I.29 (Friedlein pp. 364–373) forms an essential link in Book I’s systematic construction of plane geometry.
Friedlein Loci Cited in GEOMETOR (5 Loci in pp. 364–373)¶
Friedlein 365–373 (text) — Grand excursion under Prop. I.29: Claudius Ptolemy’s attempted proof of Postulate 5, Proclus’s refutation of its hidden assumption, and Proclus’s own bounded-divergence proof. -
hoenen: Hoenen Caput I, §5, p. 15 [folio0015]Friedlein 365, 7–11 (text) — Citation of Claudius Ptolemy’s treatise ‘That straight lines produced from angles less than two right angles meet’ and summary of his preliminary lemmas. -
euclid(proclus:in-euclid:365.7-11): Heath Vol. I, p. 204 (Bk. I, first_principles) [folio0218]Friedlein 365, 14–367, 27 (text) — Full reproduction of Ptolemy’s attempted symmetry proof of Prop. I.29 and deduction of Euclid’s Fifth Postulate. -
euclid(proclus:in-euclid:365.14-367.27): Heath Vol. I, p. 205 (Bk. I, first_principles) [folio0219]Friedlein 368, 26 (text) — Proclus’s critique of Ptolemy’s parallel proof and refutation of a Zeno/Achilles-style infinite-bisection sophism claiming converging lines never meet. -
euclid(proclus:in-euclid:368.26): Heath Vol. I, p. 206 (Bk. I, first_principles) [folio0220]Friedlein 371, 10 (text) — Proclus’s own attempted proof of Postulate 5, explicitly invoking Aristotle’s De Caelo I.5 lemma that diverging rays separate beyond any given finite distance. -
euclid(proclus:in-euclid:371.10): Heath Vol. I, p. 45 (chapter_iv) [folio0059]