Prop. I.15: Vertical Angles & Proclus’s Excursus on Porisms — GEOMETOR Commentary & Concordance Notes

GEOMETOR Philosophical & Mathematical Commentary

Proclus’s commentary on Prop. I.15 (Friedlein pp. 298–305) forms an essential link in Book I’s systematic construction of plane geometry.

Friedlein Loci Cited in GEOMETOR (8 Loci in pp. 298–305)

  • Friedlein 297, 1–298, 10 (text) — Commentary on Prop. I.14: Porphyry’s precision regarding the ‘on opposite sides’ condition in proving two adjacent supplementary rays form one straight line. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:297.1-298.10): Heath Vol. I, p. 24 (chapter_iii) [folio 0038]

  • Friedlein 298, 14–24 (text) — Commentary on Prop. I.15: exact distinction between adjacent angles (ephexes) and vertical angles (kata koryphen). - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:298.14-24): Heath Vol. I, p. 278 (Bk. I, propositions) [folio 0292]

  • Friedlein 299, 3–6 (text) — Eudemus’s testimony that Thales first discovered the equality of vertical angles (Prop. I.15), while Euclid first gave its scientific demonstration. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:299.3-6): Heath Vol. I, p. 278 (Bk. I, propositions) [folio 0292]

  • Friedlein 303–304 (text) — Excursus on Porisms following Prop. I.15: distinction between Corollary-Porisms and the higher Porisms of Euclid’s lost three-book treatise. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:303-4): Heath Vol. I, p. 82 (chapter_vii) [folio 0096]

  • Friedlein 303, 6 (text) — Characterization of a Porism as an unintended ‘windfall’ or ‘gain’ (kerdos) emerging directly from a completed demonstration. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:303-6): Heath Vol. II, p. 175 (Bk. V, propositions) [folio 0181]

  • Friedlein 304–305 (text) — Examples of geometric corollaries and porismatic deductions in the Elements. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:304-5): Heath Vol. II, p. 98 (Bk. IV, propositions) [folio 0104]

  • Friedlein 304, 2 (text) — Classification of Porisms into geometric vs. arithmetic, following either theorems (as I.15 Porism) or problems (as IV.15 Porism). - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:304-2): Heath Vol. II, p. 109 (Bk. IV, propositions) [folio 0115]

  • Friedlein 305, 24 (text) — Opening of Prop. I.16 commentary: why omitting the construction misleads critics like Philippus into questioning the exterior-angle enunciation. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:305.24): Heath Vol. I, p. 20 (chapter_iii) [folio 0034]