Prop. I.9: Bisection of a Rectilineal Angle & Trisection Analysis — GEOMETOR Commentary & Concordance Notes

GEOMETOR Philosophical & Mathematical Commentary

Proclus’s commentary on Prop. I.9 (Friedlein pp. 270–277) forms an essential link in Book I’s systematic construction of plane geometry.

Friedlein Loci Cited in GEOMETOR (4 Loci in pp. 270–277)

  • Friedlein 270, 5–24 (text) — Commentary on Prop. I.9: refutation of objections to Euclid’s angle-bisection construction (ensuring the inner equilateral vertex lies cleanly within the angle). - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:270.5-24): Heath Vol. I, p. 45 (chapter_iv) [folio 0059]

  • Friedlein 272, 3–7 (text) — Why trisecting a general rectilinear angle transcends straightedge and compass, requiring Nicomedes’ conchoids, Hippias’s quadratrices, or Archimedes’ spirals. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:272.3-7): Heath Vol. I, p. 161 (Bk. I, first_principles) [folio 0175]

  • Friedlein 272, 10 (text) — Historical record of angle-trisection curves (Nicomedes, Hippias, Archimedes) in Hellenistic geometry. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:272.10): Heath Vol. I, p. 26 (chapter_iii) [folio 0040]

  • Friedlein 277, 25–279, 4 (text) — Commentary on Prop. I.10: refutation of Xenocrates’ doctrine of indivisible lines (atomoi grammai) from the universal bisectability of segments. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:277.25-279.4): Heath Vol. I, p. 268 (Bk. I, propositions) [folio 0282]