Prop. I.4: First Congruence Theorem (SAS) & Superposition — GEOMETOR Commentary & Concordance Notes

GEOMETOR Philosophical & Mathematical Commentary

Proclus’s commentary on Prop. I.4 (Friedlein pp. 233–243) forms an essential link in Book I’s systematic construction of plane geometry.

Friedlein Loci Cited in GEOMETOR (4 Loci in pp. 233–243)

  • Friedlein 234, 21 (text) — Commentary on Prop. I.4: why this is the first Theorem in the Elements and why SAS congruence relies on superposition (epharmoge) without prior theorems. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:234.21): Heath Vol. I, p. 128 (chapter_ix) [folio 0142]

  • Friedlein 241, 19–243, 11 (text) — Carpus of Antioch (in his Astronomical Treatise) vs. Geminus on whether Problems precede Theorems in natural order. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:241.19-243.11): Heath Vol. I, p. 127 (chapter_ix) [folio 0141]

  • Friedlein 241, 21 (text) — Citation of Carpus the Mechanician (‘Carpus of Antioch’) on the methodological priority of Problems. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:241.21): Heath Vol. I, p. 44 (chapter_iv) [folio 0058]

  • Friedlein 242, 16 (text) — Proclus’s synthesis resolving Carpus and Geminus: problems predominate in genesis/art, theorems in dignity and contemplative science. - euclid (proclus:in-euclid:242.16): Heath Vol. I, p. 140 (chapter_ix) [folio 0154]