The Six Permutations ($S_3$) & The Two Star Points

Symmetric Group Action on Six Collinear Vertices

A single instance of Pappus’s Hexagon Theorem fixes an ordering of the two collinear triples $(A_0, A_1, A_2)$ on carrier $a$ and $(B_0, B_1, B_2)$ on carrier $b$. Yet the nine cross-lines $\{[A_i B_j] : 0 \le i, j \le 2\}$ exist independently of how the indices on $b$ are labeled!

Hold $(A_0, A_1, A_2)$ fixed and let the symmetric group $S_3$ of order $3! = 6$ permute the labels on $b$ via $\sigma = (\sigma_0, \sigma_1, \sigma_2) \in S_3$. Each permutation inscribes a distinct hexagon

\[H_\sigma = \langle A_0,\, B_{\sigma_1},\, A_2,\, B_{\sigma_0},\, A_1,\, B_{\sigma_2} \rangle,\]

whose three opposite cross-join intersections

\[M_{01}^{(\sigma)} = [A_0 B_{\sigma_1}] \cap [A_1 B_{\sigma_0}], \quad M_{12}^{(\sigma)} = [A_1 B_{\sigma_2}] \cap [A_2 B_{\sigma_1}], \quad M_{20}^{(\sigma)} = [A_2 B_{\sigma_0}] \cap [A_0 B_{\sigma_2}]\]

determine a distinct Pappus line $p_\sigma$. Across all six elements of $S_3$, the nine cross-lines meet in 18 cross-join intersections arranged three-by-three along six Pappus lines—splitting cleanly by permutation parity into the alternating subgroup $A_3 = \{(0,1,2),\, (1,2,0),\, (2,0,1)\}$ (even, 3-cycles) and its odd coset $S_3 \setminus A_3 = \{(0,2,1),\, (1,0,2),\, (2,1,0)\}$ (odd, transpositions).

Exact Six $S_3$ Pappus Lines on preset="steiner" ($A = [(1,0),(2,0),(3,0)]$, $B = [(0,2),(3,1),(5,\tfrac{1}{3})]$)

$\sigma \in S_3$

Parity

Three Collinear Cross-Join Meets

Exact Line Equation

$(0, 1, 2)$

even

$\left(\frac{5}{3}, \frac{1}{3}\right),\; \left(3, \frac{1}{9}\right),\; \left(\frac{25}{9}, \frac{4}{27}\right)$

$3x + 18y = 11$

$(1, 2, 0)$

even

$\left(\frac{23}{11}, \frac{1}{11}\right),\; \left(\frac{15}{7}, -\frac{1}{7}\right),\; (3, -4)$

$9x + 2y = 19$

$(2, 0, 1)$

even

$\left(\frac{20}{19}, -\frac{2}{19}\right),\; \left(\frac{12}{5}, \frac{2}{5}\right),\; \left(0, -\frac{1}{2}\right)$

$3x - 8y = 4$

$(0, 2, 1)$

odd

$\left(\frac{25}{13}, \frac{1}{13}\right),\; \left(\frac{9}{5}, -\frac{1}{5}\right),\; \left(\frac{15}{7}, \frac{4}{7}\right)$

$9x - 4y = 17$

$(1, 0, 2)$

odd

$\left(\frac{4}{3}, -\frac{2}{3}\right),\; \left(\frac{20}{7}, \frac{2}{21}\right),\; \left(3, \frac{1}{6}\right)$

$3x - 6y = 8$

$(2, 1, 0)$

odd

$\left(\frac{5}{7}, -\frac{1}{7}\right),\; (3, -1),\; \left(\frac{15}{13}, -\frac{4}{13}\right)$

$3x + 8y = 1$

Jakob Steiner’s Theorem (1828): The Two Star Points

In 1828, Jakob Steiner discovered a remarkable higher-order concurrency hidden inside the six Pappus lines: they do not meet in 15 generic points, nor do all six concur at a single point. Instead, concurrency respects permutation parity:

  • The three even Pappus lines ($\sigma \in A_3$, amber) concur at a single point, the even Steiner Star point $S_+$.

  • The three odd Pappus lines ($\sigma \in S_3 \setminus A_3$, magenta) concur at a second point, the odd Steiner Star point $S_-$.

The Six Pappus Lines and Two Steiner Star Points (S+, S-) [ A0 B0 ]: -2*x - y + 2 = 0 [ A0 B1 ]: -x + 2*y + 1 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -x/3 + 4*y + 1/3 = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -2*x - 2*y + 4 = 0 [ A1 B1 ]: -x + y + 2 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -x/3 + 3*y + 2/3 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -2*x - 3*y + 6 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: x - 3 = 0 [ A2 B2 ]: -x/3 + 2*y + 1 = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: 5*x/3 + 5*y - 10 = 0 [ M0110 M1221 ]: 2*x/9 + 4*y/3 - 22/27 = 0 [ M0210 M1122 ]: 18*x/65 - 8*y/65 - 34/65 = 0 [ M0011 M1220 ]: -16*x/21 + 32*y/21 + 128/63 = 0 [ M0211 M1022 ]: 18*x/77 + 4*y/77 - 38/77 = 0 [ M0012 M1120 ]: -48*x/95 + 128*y/95 + 64/95 = 0 [ M0112 M1021 ]: 6*x/7 + 16*y/7 - 2/7 = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: 10*x/13 - 5*y/13 - 115/78 = 0 A0 = (1, 0) A1 = (2, 0) A2 = (3, 0) B0 = (0, 2) B1 = (3, 1) B2 = (5, 1/3) O = (6, 0) M0110 = (5/3, 1/3) M1221 = (3, 1/9) M0220 = (25/9, 4/27) M0210 = (25/13, 1/13) M1122 = (9/5, -1/5) M0120 = (15/7, 4/7) M0011 = (4/3, -2/3) M1220 = (20/7, 2/21) M0221 = (3, 1/6) M0211 = (23/11, 1/11) M1022 = (15/7, -1/7) M0021 = (3, -4) M0012 = (20/19, -2/19) M1120 = (12/5, 2/5) M0122 = (0, -1/2) M0112 = (5/7, -1/7) M1021 = (3, -1) M0022 = (15/13, -4/13) S1 = (80/39, 7/26) S2 = (5/3, -1/2) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 O S+ S−
step Trace the three even ($A_3$) Pappus lines: p012, p120, and p201.
step Verify their exact concurrency at the even Star point S_+ $= \left(\frac{80}{39},\, \frac{7}{26}\right)$: $3\left(\frac{80}{39}\right) + 18\left(\frac{7}{26}\right) = \frac{80 + 63}{13} = 11$, $9\left(\frac{80}{39}\right) + 2\left(\frac{7}{26}\right) = \frac{240 + 7}{13} = 19$, and $3\left(\frac{80}{39}\right) - 8\left(\frac{7}{26}\right) = \frac{80 - 28}{13} = 4$.
step Trace the three odd ($S_3 \setminus A_3$) Pappus lines: p021, p102, and p210.
step Verify their exact concurrency at the odd Star point S_- $= \left(\frac{5}{3},\, -\frac{1}{2}\right)$, and join the two Star points along the dashed violet Steiner line S_+S_- ($12x - 6y = 23$).

GEOMETOR’s 2023 Parallel Configuration Discovery

In GEOMETOR’s original 2023 pappus.py exploration ($A = [(0,0), (1,0), (3,0)]$ on $y = 0$ and $B = [(0,1), (3/2, 1), (5/2, 1)]$ on $y = 1$), constructing all nine cross-lines uncovered both a subtle projective phenomenon and exact rational Star coordinates:

  • Because $[A_0 B_1]$ and $[A_1 B_2]$ share exact slope $\frac{2}{3}$, one of the 18 cross-join pairs meets at an ideal point on the line at infinity, leaving 17 finite cross-join meets in $\mathbb{Q}^2$. On the odd transposition $\sigma = (2, 1, 0)$, that parallel cross-join pair $[A_0 B_1] \parallel [A_1 B_2]$ directs its Pappus line along exact slope $\frac{2}{3}$ toward the ideal meet!

  • All three even Pappus lines meet inside the central strip at the exact rational Star point

    \[S_+ = \left(\frac{90}{73},\; \frac{38}{73}\right),\]

    while the three odd Pappus lines concur far in the first quadrant at $S_- = \left(10,\; \frac{38}{3}\right)$.

2023 GEOMETOR Parallel Configuration — Even Star Point S+ = (90/73, 38/73) [ A0 B0 ]: x = 0 [ A0 B1 ]: -x + 3*y/2 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -x + 5*y/2 = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -x - y + 1 = 0 [ A1 B1 ]: -x + y/2 + 1 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -x + 3*y/2 + 1 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -x - 3*y + 3 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: -x - 3*y/2 + 3 = 0 [ A2 B2 ]: -x - y/2 + 3 = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: y - 1 = 0 [ M0110 M1221 ]: -4*x/15 + 7*y/5 - 2/5 = 0 [ M0210 M1122 ]: -12*x/7 + 9*y/7 + 6/7 = 0 [ M0011 M1220 ]: -22*x/9 + 5*y/3 + 10/3 = 0 [ M0211 M1022 ]: 9*x/2 + 15*y/4 - 15/2 = 0 [ M0012 M1120 ]: -26*x/21 + 9*y/7 + 6/7 = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: -2660*x/219 + 640*y/73 + 760/73 = 0 A0 = (0, 0) A1 = (1, 0) A2 = (3, 0) B0 = (0, 1) B1 = (3/2, 1) B2 = (5/2, 1) M0110 = (3/5, 2/5) M1221 = (2, 2/3) M0220 = (15/11, 6/11) M0210 = (5/7, 2/7) M1122 = (2, 2) M0120 = (1, 2/3) M1220 = (5/3, 4/9) M0221 = (15/8, 3/4) M0211 = (5/4, 1/2) M0021 = (0, 2) M0012 = (0, -2/3) M1120 = (9/7, 4/7) M0122 = (9/4, 3/2) S1 = (90/73, 38/73) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 S+
step Observe the three even Pappus lines p012, p120, and p201 converging inside the parallel carrier band at S_+ $= \left(\frac{90}{73}, \frac{38}{73}\right)$.