Book III · Summary & Exact Symbolic Audit (Three Means & Problem Hierarchy)

Structural Argument Map & geometor.pappus Symbolic Verification

1. Methodological Architecture (Hultsch I, pp. 30–68)

  • Theorem vs. Problem: A theorem demonstrates a necessary consequence of given hypotheses; a problem constructs a sought figure subject to a diorismos specifying existence and multiplicity.

  • Threefold Classification of Loci: 1. Plane (ἐπίπεδα): straight lines and circles (Elements I–VI). 2. Solid (στερεά): conic sections (Apollonius Conics; required for Delian two mean proportionals $a : x = x : y = y : b$ and angle trisection). 3. Linear (γραμμικά): higher kinematic or locus curves (Archimedean spiral, quadratrix, Nicomedean conchoid, Dioclean cissoid).

2. Semicircle Synthesis of the Three Classical Means (Hultsch I, pp. 68–84)

Given positive magnitudes $a = AD$ and $b = DC$ placed along diameter $AC = a + b$ of a semicircle with center $O$:

Mean (Μεσότης)

Semicircle Segment

Closed-Form Formula

Rational Preset $(9, 16)$ & Golden Preset $(1, \phi^2)$

Arithmetic ($A$)

Radius $OB$

$A = \dfrac{a + b}{2}$

$A = \dfrac{25}{2} \quad \big| \quad A = \dfrac{\phi + 2}{2}$

Geometric ($G$)

Perpendicular $DB$

$G = \sqrt{ab}$

$G = 12 \quad \big| \quad G = \phi$

Harmonic ($H$)

Projection $BF$ on $OB$

$H = \dfrac{2ab}{a + b}$

$H = \dfrac{288}{25} \quad \big| \quad H = \dfrac{2\phi^2}{\phi + 2}$

3. Exact Invariants Verified in geometor.pappus

Implemented in geometor.pappus.construct_three_means() (see demos/synagoge_three_means.py):

  • Proportional Identity: $A \cdot H = \left(\frac{a + b}{2}\right)\left(\frac{2ab}{a + b}\right) = ab = G^2$ — i.e., $G$ is the geometric mean between $A$ and $H$.

  • Geometric Ordering: Nested right triangles $\triangle ODB$ and $\triangle DFB$ immediately yield $OB \ge DB \ge BF$, proving $A \ge G \ge H$ with equality iff $a = b$ ($D = O$).

  • Projective Harmonic Range: Tangent $BT \perp OB$ meets $AC$ produced at $T = \left(-\frac{a(a+b)}{b - a}, 0\right)$ (for $a < b$ with $A$ at the origin), establishing the four-point harmonic cross-ratio $(A, C; D, T) = -1$.

Exact rational coordinates produced by construct_three_means(9, 16):

  • $A = (0, 0)$, $D = (9, 0)$, $O = \left(\frac{25}{2}, 0\right)$, $C = (25, 0)$, $B = (9, 12)$, $F = \left(\frac{7641}{625}, \frac{588}{625}\right)$, $T = \left(-\frac{225}{7}, 0\right)$, satisfying $\operatorname{CR}(A, C; D, T) = -1$ identically.