Scholarly & GEOMETOR Notes: Spherical Incenter and Ceva’s Concurrency¶
From Menelaus III.9 to Ceva’s Concurrency Criterion
1. Antecedent of Ceva’s Concurrency¶
Proposition III.9 proves that the three angle bisectors of a spherical triangle concur. Written around 100 CE, it is one of the earliest rigorous concurrence proofs for spherical cevians in the history of geometry.
Multiplying the three bisector ratios:
\[\frac{\sin\widehat{A E}}{\sin\widehat{E \Gamma}}
\cdot
\frac{\sin\widehat{\Gamma D}}{\sin\widehat{D B}}
\cdot
\frac{\sin\widehat{B F}}{\sin\widehat{F A}}
\;=\;
\frac{\sin c}{\sin a}
\cdot
\frac{\sin a}{\sin b}
\cdot
\frac{\sin b}{\sin c}
\;=\; +1,\]
which is the exact Spherical Ceva Condition for internal angle bisectors!
2. Role in Proposition III.10¶
Proposition III.9 serves as the critical intermediate step in Menelaus’s proof of Proposition III.10 (concurrency of altitudes). Menelaus proves that the altitudes of triangle \(\triangle AB\Gamma\) are the angle bisectors of its orthic triangle \(\triangle \Delta EH\), and applies Proposition III.9 to establish their concurrence!