Proposition III.1 — The Spherical Menelaus Transversal Theorem

Menelai Alexandrini Sphaericorum Lib. III Prop. I. Theor. (Halley 1758, pp. 80–82)

Proposition III.1 — Theorem: Theorema Menelai / Figura Catha (pp. 80–82)

Enunciation (Halley 1758, p. 80)

Let there be upon the surface of a sphere two arcs of great circles \(\mathrm{NME}\), \(\mathrm{NA\Lambda}\), between which let two other great-circle arcs \(\mathrm{E\Theta A}\), \(\mathrm{\Lambda\Theta M}\) be drawn meeting one another at point \(\mathrm{\Theta}\): I say that the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{AN}}\) has to the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{A\Lambda}}\) a ratio compounded of the ratio which the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{NE}}\) has to the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{EM}}\), and of the ratio which the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{M\Theta}}\) has to the sine of arc \(\widehat{\mathrm{\Theta\Lambda}}\).

A = (0, 0, 1) B = (3/5, 4/5, 0) C = (2/3, 2/3, 1/3) D = (9*sqrt(181)/181, 8*sqrt(181)/181, 6*sqrt(181)/181) E = (sqrt(3)/3, sqrt(3)/3, sqrt(3)/3) F = (3*sqrt(61)/61, 4*sqrt(61)/61, 6*sqrt(61)/61) A B C D E F
Exact spherical Menelaus configuration on the unit sphere S² (Sphaerica Prop. III.1): great-circle transversal DF cuts the sides of spherical triangle △ABC at D (external on BC), E, and F.

On the unit sphere S², great-circle transversal DF cuts the sides of spherical triangle A, B, C (AB, BC, CA) at D (external on BC), E, and F, satisfying:

\[\frac{\sin\widehat{AF}}{\sin\widehat{FB}} \cdot \frac{\sin\widehat{BD}}{\sin\widehat{DC}} \cdot \frac{\sin\widehat{CE}}{\sin\widehat{EA}} = -1.\]

[§3.1 · Menelaus’s Gnomonic-Chord Demonstration, Halley pp. 80–82] Let point \(\mathrm{B}\) be set as the center of the sphere, and join straight lines (chords and radii) \(\mathrm{\Lambda N}\), \(\mathrm{\Lambda M}\), \(\mathrm{MN}\), \(\mathrm{EB}\), and \(\mathrm{\Theta B}\) meeting chord \(\mathrm{M\Lambda}\) at \(\mathrm{\Delta}\), and radius \(\mathrm{AB}\) meeting chord \(\mathrm{N\Lambda}\) at \(\mathrm{\Sigma}\); and let straight line \(\mathrm{\Delta\Sigma}\) be drawn and produced until it meets straight line \(\mathrm{MN}\) produced at \(\mathrm{K}\):

  1. Point \(\mathrm{K}\) lies in the plane of both great circles \(\mathrm{A\Theta E}\) and \(\mathrm{NME}\). Since points \(\mathrm{E}\) and \(\mathrm{B}\) also lie in both planes, \(\mathrm{KEB}\) is a single straight line (Euclid Elements XI.3).

  2. In the planar triangle \(\triangle \mathrm{N\Lambda M}\), point \(\mathrm{\Sigma}\) lies on \(\mathrm{N\Lambda}\), point \(\mathrm{\Delta}\) lies on \(\mathrm{M\Lambda}\), and point \(\mathrm{K}\) lies on \(\mathrm{MN}\) produced, with \(\mathrm{\Sigma}, \mathrm{\Delta}, \mathrm{K}\) collinear. Therefore, by the Planar Menelaus Lemma (per sequens Lemma I), the ratio \(\mathrm{N\Sigma} : \mathrm{\Sigma\Lambda}\) is compounded of \(\mathrm{NK} : \mathrm{KM}\) and \(\mathrm{M\Delta} : \mathrm{\Delta\Lambda}\).

  3. By the Chord-Sine Lemma (per Lemma II), \(\mathrm{NK} : \mathrm{KM}\) equals the perpendicular dropped from \(\mathrm{N}\) onto diameter \(\mathrm{KEB}\) to the perpendicular from \(\mathrm{M}\) onto the same diameter—that is, \(\sin \widehat{\mathrm{NE}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{EM}}\). Likewise \(\mathrm{N\Sigma} : \mathrm{\Sigma\Lambda} = \sin \widehat{\mathrm{NA}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{A\Lambda}}\), and \(\mathrm{M\Delta} : \mathrm{\Delta\Lambda} = \sin \widehat{\mathrm{M\Theta}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{\Theta\Lambda}}\).

  4. Hence \(\sin \widehat{\mathrm{AN}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{A\Lambda}}\) is compounded of \(\sin \widehat{\mathrm{NE}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{EM}}\) and \(\sin \widehat{\mathrm{M\Theta}} : \sin \widehat{\mathrm{\Theta\Lambda}}\). Q.E.D.

[§3.2 · Limiting Parallel Case & Alternation, pp. 81–82] Menelaus immediately treats the singular case where chord \(\mathrm{\Delta\Sigma}\) is parallel to chord \(\mathrm{MN}\) (so \(\mathrm{K}\) recedes to infinity along the common diameter \(\mathrm{EBK}\) parallel to both, by Euclid Elements XI.9): then the perpendiculars from \(\mathrm{N}\) and \(\mathrm{M}\) onto \(\mathrm{EBK}\) are equal (\(\sin \widehat{\mathrm{NE}} = \sin \widehat{\mathrm{EM}}\), occurring when \(\widehat{\mathrm{EM}} + \widehat{\mathrm{NE}}\) equals a semicircle!), and the first factor becomes the ratio of equality (\(1 : 1\)). Inverting the compounded ratio yields the companion katà diaíresin identity:

\[\frac{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{A\Lambda}}}{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{AN}}} \;=\; \frac{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{\Lambda\Theta}}}{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{\Theta M}}} \cdot \frac{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{ME}}}{\sin \widehat{\mathrm{EN}}}.\]