Scholarly & GEOMETOR Notes: Book II Numbering & Stemmatics

Philological Notes on Book II Propositions

1. Medieval Proposition Numbering

As documented by Axel Anthon Björnbo (1902, §§6–8), medieval manuscript traditions vary considerably in how they count propositions across Book II:

  • Gerard of Cremona’s Toledo Latin Version: 19 numbered propositions.

  • Abū Naṣr Manṣūr’s 1007 CE Redaction: 10 propositions.

  • Edmond Halley’s 1758 Oxford Edition: 12 propositions (combining several sub-cases).

2. Systematic Independence from 3D Chords

Every witness, however, agrees on the structural core: Menelaus consistently avoids 3D chord intersections, relying entirely on intrinsic angle and arc comparisons on the surface of \(S^2\).