Analytical Summary: The Intrinsic Axiomatic Shift¶
Axiomatic Foundations of Menelaus’s Sphaerica
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Geometry: Before Menelaus, Greek treatises on the sphere—notably Autolycus of Pitane (On the Moving Sphere) and Theodosius of Bithynia (Sphaerica)—treated geometric configurations on a sphere purely from an extrinsic three-dimensional viewpoint, slicing the solid sphere by Euclidean planes and examining straight chords and solid angles. Menelaus takes the revolutionary conceptual step of treating the spherical surface \(S^2\) as a two-dimensional geometric arena endowed with its own intrinsic geodesic lines (arcs of great circles).
The Minor Arc Condition (Definition II): By restricting the sides of a spherical triangle to arcs strictly less than a semicircle (\(< \pi\)), Menelaus ensures the uniqueness of geodesic segments between vertices. If arcs equal to or greater than a semicircle were permitted, antipodal vertices would admit infinitely many joining arcs, destroying triangular uniqueness.
Dihedral Angle Equivalence (Definitions III–VI): A spherical angle formed by two intersecting great-circle arcs is defined by the dihedral inclination of their containing diametral planes. Two spherical angles are equal when their planes meet with equal inclination, and a spherical angle is right when its containing planes are perpendicular.