Summary: Libro X — Napoleon’s Problem & Minimal-Instrument Duality

Algorithmic Duality of Center Determination

1. The Center Problem Ledger

Center Determination: Mascheroni vs. Steiner

Instrument Regime

Status of Center \(O\)

Constructive Possibility

Mascheroni (Compass Alone)

Circle \(\Gamma\) given without center

Solvable: Found in 6 circles (\(S = 15\)) via inversion

Steiner (Straightedge Alone)

Circle \(\Omega\) given without center

Impossible: Collineations fixing \(\Omega\) move center \(M\)

Poncelet–Steiner (Straightedge)

Circle \(\Omega\) given with center \(M\)

Solvable: Restores full Euclidean quadratic closure

2. Algebraic Invariants of Napoleon’s Problem

For given circle \(\Gamma(O, R)\) and arbitrary point \(A\) on \(\Gamma\):

\[AB = AC = r, \qquad AD = \frac{r^2}{R}, \qquad \text{Inversion of } D \text{ through } A(r) \implies AO = \frac{r^2}{AD} = R.\]

Because \(D\) lies on diameter \(AO\), the inverse of \(D\) through circle \(A(r)\) falls at distance \(R\) from \(A\) along the diameter, which is precisely the center \(O\)!