Summary: The Scope and Axiomatic Foundation of Compass-Only Geometry

Structural Overview of Mascheroni’s 1797 Treatise and Operational Principles

1. The Postulate of the Single Instrument

In classical Euclidean geometry (euclid-heath), constructive power rests upon three postulates:

  • Postulate 1: To draw a straight line from any point to any point.

  • Postulate 2: To produce a finite straight line continuously in a straight line.

  • Postulate 3: To describe a circle with any center and radius.

Lorenzo Mascheroni proved that Postulates 1 and 2 can be entirely eliminated for all point-determination problems in plane geometry. The geometer requires only Postulate 3.

2. The Virtual Line Principle

Because a continuous straight line cannot be traced without a straightedge, Mascheroni introduces the fundamental concept of the virtual line:

  • Any straight line \(L\) is determined and represented by two distinct points \((A, B)\).

  • A third point \(C\) is said to lie on line \((A, B)\) if its distance from \(A\) and \(B\) satisfies the collinear triangle-inequality degenerate limit \(AB + BC = AC\) or \(AC + CB = AB\).

  • All operations on straight lines—drawing parallels, erecting perpendiculars, reflecting across lines, and intersecting lines with circles or with other lines—are executed purely by intersecting circular arcs.

3. Systematic Codex Division

Mascheroni’s Twelve Books and Primary Constructive Invariants

Book

Canonical Title

Key Problem Solved

Operation Count

Libro I

Preliminari (§§ 1–11)

Virtual line representation & arc meets

\(2C_1 + C_3\)

Libro II

Divisione della circonferenza (§§ 12–63)

Circle quadrisection, golden ratio

4 auxiliary arcs

Libro III

Moltiplicazione e divisione (§§ 64–75)

Linear doubling § 64, bisection § 66

\(10C_1 + 7C_3\) (\(S = 17\))

Libro IV

Perpendicolari e parallele (§§ 76–85)

Perpendiculars § 76, parallels § 80

\(5C_1 + 2C_3\) (\(S = 7\))

Libro V

Distanze proporzionali (§§ 86–101)

Fourth proportional via concentric circles

4 circles (\(S = 14\))

Libro VII

Intersezioni rette-cerchi (§§ 110–112)

Line–circle and line–line meets

Inversion \(5C_1 + 3C_3\)

Libro X

Determinazione dei centri (§§ 143–155)

Finding circle center (Napoleon)

Pure compass sweep