§ 25: The Commutative and the Associative Law of Addition for Our New Algebra of Segments¶
David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)
In this section, we shall investigate the laws of operation, as enumerated in § 13, in order to see which of these hold for our new algebra of segments, when we base our considerations upon a plane geometry in which axioms I 1–2, II–III are all fulfilled, and, moreover, in which Desargues’s theorem also holds.
First of all, we shall show that, for the addition of segments as defined in § 24, the commutative law
$$ a+ b = b+a $$
holds. Let
$$ \begin{aligned} &\; a = OA = OA' \; \\ &\; b = OB = OB' \; \end{aligned} $$
Hence, $AA'$ and $BB'$ are, according to our convention, parallel to the unit-line. Construct the points $A''$ and $B''$ by drawing $A'A''$ and $B'B''$ parallel to $OA$ and also $AB''$ and $BA'$ parallel to $OA$. We see at once that the line $A''B''$ is parallel to $AA'$ as the commutative law requires. We shall show the validity of this statement by the aid of Desargues’s theorem in the following manner. Denote the point of intersection of $AB''$ and $A'A''$ by $F$ and that of $BA''$ and $B'B''$ by $D$. Then, in the triangles $AA'F$ and $BB'D$, the homologous sides are parallel to each other. By Desargues’s theorem, it follows that the three points $O$, $F$, $D$ lie in a straight line. In consequence of this condition, the two triangles $OAA'$ and $DB''A''$ lie in such a way that the lines joining the corresponding vertices pass through the same point $F$, and since the homologous sides $OA$ and $DB''$, as also $OA'$ and $DA''$, are parallel to each other, then, according to the second part of Desargues’s theorem (theorem 32), the third sides $AA'$ and $B''A''$ are parallel to each other.
To prove the associative law of addition
$$ a+(b+c)=(a+b)+c, $$
we shall make use of figure 44. In consequence of the commutative law of addition just demonstrated, the above formula states that the straight line $A''B''$ must be parallel to the unit-line.
The validity of this statement is evident, since the shaded part of figure 44 corresponds exactly with figure 43.