§ 23: The Impossibility of Demonstrating Desargues’s Theorem for the Plane Without the Help of the Axioms of Congruence — Summary¶
Structural & Mathematical Overview — § 23: Die Nichtbeweisbarkeit des Desarguesschen Satzes in der Ebene ohne Hülfe der Congruenzaxiome
Parallel Reading Tracks¶
English (1902 Townsend): § 23 (p. 74)
Deutsch (1899 Teubner): § 23 (S. 51)
Section Overview¶
§ 23 — Hilbert’s Non-Desarguesian Plane (Theorem 33): Constructs a celebrated planar countermodel inside the Euclidean $XY$-plane: straight lines cutting the ellipse $x^2 + 4y^2 = 1$ have their interior chord replaced by the circular arc passing through the two boundary intersections $P, Q$ and the exterior point $F(\tfrac{3}{2}, 0)$ (since $\tfrac{3}{2} > \tfrac{\sqrt{7}}{2}$, no circle meeting the ellipse four times can pass through $F$). This deformed plane satisfies all planar axioms `I 1–2, II, III, IV 1–5, V` while violating Desargues’s Theorem—proving planar Desargues unprovable without either 3D spatial incidence (I 3–7) or triangle congruence (IV 6)!