DISTINCTIO VI — SOLID MENSURATION & THE FIVE REGULAR POLYHEDRA

Prisms, Pyramids, Cones, Spheres, and the Inscription of the Five Platonic Solids in Sphere Diameter 6

Source Text: fibonacci:pg-6 (Boncompagni Vol. II, pp. 158–202 · fol. 100r–130v) · Latin (1220 / Boncompagni 1862) · Summary · GEOMETOR Notes


Part I — Dimension of Prisms, Pyramids, Cones, and Spheres

Latin Locus: Distinctio VI (Pars I) — De Dimensione Corporum (pp. 158–190) · Commentary: Notes on Archimedes & Stereometry

Here begins the Sixth Distinction, on the dimension of bodies (in dimensione corporum).

There are many kinds of solid bodies, among which are these: rectangular solids, wedges, pyramids, columns (prisms and cylinders), spheres and their parts, and those bodies called many-based which are inscribed or circumscribed about spheres.

  1. Prisms and Cylinders: Measured by multiplying the area of the base (embadum) into the perpendicular altitude (cathetus). [XII. 11]

  2. Pyramids and Cones: Every pyramid or cone is exactly one-third of the prism or cylinder having the same base and the same altitude: $V = \frac{1}{3} B h$. [XII. 7, 10]

  3. Frustums of Pyramids and Cones (Pyramis caput abscisa): Measured by multiplying one-third of the altitude into the sum of the base area $B_1$, the top area $B_2$, and their geometric mean $\sqrt{B_1 B_2}$:

    $$V = \frac{h}{3}\left(B_1 + B_2 + \sqrt{B_1 B_2}\right).$$

  4. The Sphere: From Archimedes’ treatise On the Sphere and Cylinder (archimedes:sphere), the volume of every sphere is two-thirds of the circumscribed cylinder whose diameter and altitude equal the diameter $d$ of the sphere:

    $$V = \frac{2}{3} \cdot \left(\frac{11}{14} d^2 \cdot d\right) = \frac{11}{21} d^3.$$

    And the surface area of the sphere is four times the area of its greatest circle: $S = 4 \cdot \frac{11}{14} d^2 = \frac{22}{7} d^2$.


f. boncompagni_1862_vol2_practica_geometriae:0197 · p. 190–196

Part II — The Five Regular Polyhedra Inscribed in a Sphere of Diameter $6$

Latin Locus: De Quinque Corporibus in Spera Descriptis (pp. 190–196) · Commentary: Notes on Euclid Book XIII & Piero della Francesca

To find the edges, areas, and corporeal volumes of the five regular solid bodies of Euclid’s Book XIII (euclid:elements) inscribed in a sphere whose diameter is $6$ perticae. [XIII. 13–18]
Distinctio VI & Euclid XIII.18 — Five Regular Polyhedra in Sphere of Diameter 6 ( O A ): x**2 + y**2 - 9 = 0 [ A K ]: y = 0 / O C /: length = 3 / A C /: length = 3*sqrt(2) / K B /: length = 2*sqrt(2) / A B /: length = 2*sqrt(3) / B I /: length = 2*sqrt(6) / A N /: length = sqrt(18 - 6*sqrt(5)) / O M /: length = 3 / M I /: length = 3*sqrt(50 - 10*sqrt(5))/5 O = (0, 0) K = (-1, 0) A = (-3, 0) I = (3, 0) C = (0, 3) B = (-1, 2*sqrt(2)) M = (3*sqrt(5)/5, -6*sqrt(5)/5) N = (-3 + sqrt(12*(-2 + ((-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1)) + (2 - sqrt(2))*sqrt(-(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1))**2 + 3*(2 - sqrt(2))**2 + 3*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))/((2 - sqrt(2))**2 + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2) + sqrt(2))**2 + 12*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1 + ((2 - sqrt(2))*(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1)) - (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*sqrt(-(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1))**2 + 3*(2 - sqrt(2))**2 + 3*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))/((2 - sqrt(2))**2 + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))**2)/6, sqrt(2)*sqrt(12*(-2 + ((-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1)) + (2 - sqrt(2))*sqrt(-(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1))**2 + 3*(2 - sqrt(2))**2 + 3*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))/((2 - sqrt(2))**2 + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2) + sqrt(2))**2 + 12*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1 + ((2 - sqrt(2))*(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1)) - (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*sqrt(-(-6*sqrt(2) - 3 + (1 + 2*sqrt(2))*(2 - sqrt(2)) + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)*(-sqrt(2) - 1))**2 + 3*(2 - sqrt(2))**2 + 3*(-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))/((2 - sqrt(2))**2 + (-2*sqrt(2) - 1)**2))**2)/6) O K A I C B M N
Semicircle ( O A ) on sphere diameter AI = 6 (center O, AK = 2): tetrahedron edge / B I / (Q = 24), octahedron / A C / (Q = 18), cube / A B / (Q = 12), dodecahedron / A N / (Q = 18 - sqrt(180)), and icosahedron / M I / (Q = 18 - sqrt(64 4/5)).

Let diameter $AI = 6$ with center O in semicircle (OA). Set $AK = 2$ (one-third of $AI$), and erect perpendiculars KB and OC. [XIII. 18]

  1. Tetrahedron ($4$ Triangular Faces): Edge BI, whose square is $AI \cdot KI = 6 \times 4 = 24$ ($e_4 = \sqrt{24} = 2\sqrt{6}$), altitude $4$, and volume $V = \sqrt{192} = 8\sqrt{3}$. [XIII. 13]

  2. Cube ($6$ Square Faces): Edge AB, whose square is $AI \cdot AK = 6 \times 2 = 12$ ($e_6 = \sqrt{12} = 2\sqrt{3}$), and volume $V = \sqrt{1{,}728} = 24\sqrt{3}$. [XIII. 15]

  3. Octahedron ($8$ Triangular Faces): Edge AC, whose square is $AO^2 + OC^2 = 3^2 + 3^2 = 18$ ($e_8 = \sqrt{18} = 3\sqrt{2}$), composed of two square pyramids, yielding the exact integer rational volume $V = 36$! [XIII. 14]


f. boncompagni_1862_vol2_practica_geometriae:0203 · p. 196–202

Part III — Extreme and Mean Ratio: Dodecahedron and Icosahedron

Latin Locus: Modus Dividendi Lineam Media et Extrema Proportione (pp. 196–202) · Commentary: Notes on Hypsicles’ XIV & Pacioli

Distinctio VI — Modus Dividendi Lineam Media et Extrema Proportione ( E M ): y**2 + (x - 2*sqrt(3))**2 - 3 = 0 ( C E ): (x - 2*sqrt(3))**2 + (y - sqrt(3))**2 - 3 = 0 ( B D ): x**2 + y**2 - (-2*sqrt(3) + 2*sqrt(15)/5)**2 - (-sqrt(3) + sqrt(15)/5)**2 = 0 [ B G ]: y = 0 [ B D ]: -sqrt(3)*x + 2*sqrt(3)*y = 0 / E C /: length = sqrt(3) / A B /: length = sqrt(18 - 6*sqrt(5)) / A E /: length = sqrt(18 - 6*sqrt(5)) / B G /: length = -sqrt(3) + sqrt(15) M = (sqrt(3), 0) B = (0, 0) E = (2*sqrt(3), 0) C = (2*sqrt(3), sqrt(3)) D = (-2*sqrt(15)/5 + 2*sqrt(3), -sqrt(15)/5 + sqrt(3)) G = (-sqrt(3) + sqrt(15), 0) A = (sqrt(3), sqrt(3)*sqrt(5 - 2*sqrt(5))) M B E C D G A
Division of pentagon chord BE = sqrt(12) in extreme and mean ratio by perpendicular / E C / = sqrt(3), circle ( C E ) and arc ( B D ), giving dodecahedron edge / B G / = / A B / = / A E / = sqrt(15) - sqrt(3).

Because the chord of the regular pentagon in the dodecahedron face is the cube edge $BE = \sqrt{12}$, Leonardo solves the edge of the regular dodecahedron by dividing $BE$ in extreme and mean ratio (media et extrema proportione) [VI. 30, XIII. 17]:

  • Bisect $BE$ at M, and through circle (EM) erect perpendicular EC $= \frac{1}{2} BE = \sqrt{3}$.

  • Hypotenuse BC has square $12 + 3 = 15$.

  • Deducting radius $CD = \sqrt{3}$ by circle (CE) leaves BD $= \sqrt{15} - \sqrt{3}$.

  • Transferring $BD$ by circle (BD) to BG yields the exact edge of the dodecahedron, an apotome (Euclid X Book irrational):

    $$e_{12} = BG = \sqrt{15} - \sqrt{3}, \qquad e_{12}^2 = 18 - \sqrt{180} = 18 - 6\sqrt{5}.$$

    Its volume is $V_{12} = 30\sqrt{3} + 6\sqrt{15}$.

  • For the Icosahedron ($20$ Triangular Faces): Through radius OM, chord MI gives:

    $$e_{20}^2 = 18 - \sqrt{64\frac{4}{5}} = 18 - \frac{18}{5}\sqrt{5}, \qquad V_{20} = 18\sqrt{10 + 2\sqrt{5}}.$$

  • Hypsicles’ Book XIV Ratio: Following Hypsicles, the ratio of the volumes (and surface areas) of the dodecahedron and icosahedron inscribed in the same sphere is:

    $$\frac{V_{12}}{V_{20}} = \frac{S_{12}}{S_{20}} = \frac{\text{Cube Edge}}{\text{Icosahedron Edge}} = \sqrt{\frac{5 + \sqrt{5}}{6}} \approx 1.098\dots$$