Supplementary Chapter: Recent Elementary Geometry of the Triangle

Recent Elementary Geometry of the Triangle (pp. 165–248, Folios 0191–0274)

The Supplementary Chapter on the Recent Elementary Geometry of the Triangle was added by John Casey in the fourth edition (1886) of his Sequel and substantially expanded in the fifth (1888) and sixth (1892) editions. It marks the first comprehensive textbook synthesis in the English-speaking world of the vibrant French, Belgian, and British geometric revival inaugurated by Émile Lemoine at the 1873 Lyon Congress.

Across two comprehensive divisions, Casey presents the theory of isogonal conjugates, antiparallels, and symmedians; Lemoine’s Point $K = X(6)$ and the six-point Lemoine circles; figures directly similar and Henri Brocard’s points $\Omega, \Omega'$ and Brocard angle $\omega$; the one-parameter Tucker family of circles and Taylor’s circle; the seven-point Brocard circle; William J. M’Clelland’s metric proof of Feuerbach’s theorem; Casey’s own theory of cyclic harmonic polygons; and the associated triangle centers of Steiner, Tarry, Neuberg, and de Longchamps.


Outline of Sections

I. Symmedians, Lemoine’s Point & Lemoine Circles (pp. 165–183)

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. I & III — Symmedian Point K, First Lemoine Circle & Cosine Circle ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 ( K Cb2 ): (x - 1673/295)**2 + (y - 1176/295)**2 - 74529/3481 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ A K ]: -84*x/5 + 239*y/10 = 0 [ B K ]: -28*x/3 - 39*y/2 + 392/3 = 0 [ C K ]: 788*x/33 + 2*y - 4732/33 = 0 [ parBC ]: -12*x - 9*y + 6132/59 = 0 [ parCA ]: 12*x - 5*y - 14196/295 = 0 [ parAB ]: y - 1176/295 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) D1 = (4471/590, 2526/295) D2 = (3248/295, 1176/295) E1 = (98/59, 1176/295) E2 = (365/118, 438/59) F1 = (511/59, 0) F2 = (1183/295, 0) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) A B C O K D1 D2 E1 E2 F1 F2 ML

Supplementary Chapter, Section I: Symmedians, Lemoine’s Point & Lemoine Circles (1888 English)

Supplementary Chapter, Section I, Proposition 1 (Isogonal Concurrency & Pedal Circle). If three lines drawn from the vertices $A, B, C$ of a triangle concur at a point $P$, their three isogonal conjugates also concur at a single point $P'$ (the Isogonal Conjugate of $P$*); and the six feet of perpendiculars let fall from* $P$ and $P'$ upon the three sides of $\triangle ABC$ lie upon a single circle whose centre is the midpoint of $PP'$.

Classical Specialization: The circumcentre O and orthocentre $H$ are isogonal conjugates, and their shared six-point pedal circle (the three side midpoints and three altitude feet) is the Nine-Points Circle centered at $N = \operatorname{midpoint}(O, H)$!

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. I & III — Symmedian Point K, First Lemoine Circle & Cosine Circle ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 ( K Cb2 ): (x - 1673/295)**2 + (y - 1176/295)**2 - 74529/3481 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ A K ]: -84*x/5 + 239*y/10 = 0 [ B K ]: -28*x/3 - 39*y/2 + 392/3 = 0 [ C K ]: 788*x/33 + 2*y - 4732/33 = 0 [ parBC ]: -12*x - 9*y + 6132/59 = 0 [ parCA ]: 12*x - 5*y - 14196/295 = 0 [ parAB ]: y - 1176/295 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) D1 = (4471/590, 2526/295) D2 = (3248/295, 1176/295) E1 = (98/59, 1176/295) E2 = (365/118, 438/59) F1 = (511/59, 0) F2 = (1183/295, 0) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) A B C O K D1 D2 E1 E2 F1 F2 ML

Supplementary Chapter, Section I Summary — Symmedians & Lemoine Circles

Section I opens Casey’s celebrated Supplementary Chapter on the Recent Elementary Geometry of the Triangle:

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. I & III — Symmedian Point K, First Lemoine Circle & Cosine Circle ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 ( K Cb2 ): (x - 1673/295)**2 + (y - 1176/295)**2 - 74529/3481 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ A K ]: -84*x/5 + 239*y/10 = 0 [ B K ]: -28*x/3 - 39*y/2 + 392/3 = 0 [ C K ]: 788*x/33 + 2*y - 4732/33 = 0 [ parBC ]: -12*x - 9*y + 6132/59 = 0 [ parCA ]: 12*x - 5*y - 14196/295 = 0 [ parAB ]: y - 1176/295 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) D1 = (4471/590, 2526/295) D2 = (3248/295, 1176/295) E1 = (98/59, 1176/295) E2 = (365/118, 438/59) F1 = (511/59, 0) F2 = (1183/295, 0) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) A B C O K D1 D2 E1 E2 F1 F2 ML

Supplementary Chapter, Section I Notes — Grebe, Lemoine, d’Ocagne & Tucker

Although the minimum-square property of $K = X(6)$ had been noticed in passing by Simon Lhuilier (1809) and Ernst Wilhelm Grebe (1847—hence the German name Grebescher Punkt), modern triangle geometry began in earnest at the 1873 Lyon Congress of the Association Française pour l’Avancement des Sciences, where Émile Lemoine presented Note sur un point remarquable du plan d'un triangle, discovering both six-point circles ((Ml D1) and (K Cb2)). Ten years later, Maurice d’Ocagne (Nouvelles Annales de Mathématiques, 1883) coined the enduring French term symédiane (“symmedian”), while Robert Tucker (QJM 19, 1883) rediscovered Lemoine’s First Circle in England under the name Triplicate-Ratio Circle before recognizing it as a member of the full one-parameter Tucker family (treated in Section II).

II. Brocard Geometry, Tucker Circles & Harmonic Polygons (pp. 175–248)

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. II, V & VII — Brocard Points Ω, Ω′, Brocard Circle, Steiner X(99) & Tarry X(98) ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml O ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 397657/891136 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ O K ]: 327*x/2360 - 392*y/295 + 10647/2360 = 0 [ B Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 - 915516*y/115249 + 5564832/115249 = 0 [ C Om1 ]: 985500*x/115249 + 121725*y/115249 - 6388200/115249 = 0 [ A Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 + 697970*y/115249 = 0 [ C Om2 ]: 853788*x/115249 + 107991*y/115249 - 5564832/115249 = 0 [ A Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 + 684236*y/115249 = 0 [ B Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 - 929250*y/115249 + 7408800/115249 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) Om1 = (697970/115249, 397488/115249) Om2 = (684236/115249, 529200/115249) A1 = (3589/590, 1014/295) B1 = (3491/590, 270/59) C1 = (7, 1176/295) St = (17253/2353, -9396/2353) Tr = (15689/2353, 115233/9412) A B C O K ML Ω Ω′ A1 B1 C1 St Tr

Supplementary Chapter, Section II: Brocard Geometry, Tucker Circles & Harmonic Polygons (1888 English)

Section II, Propositions 3–5 (:person:`Brocard’s <brocard>` :term:`Points <brocard-points>` $\Omega, \Omega'$ & :term:`Brocard Angle <brocard-angle>` $\omega$). In any triangle △ABC:

  1. The three circles described on $AB$ tangent to $BC$ at $B$, on $BC$ tangent to $CA$ at $C$, and on $CA$ tangent to $AB$ at $A$ concur at a unique interior point Ω (the First Brocard Point) such that

    $$ \angle \Omega AB = \angle \Omega BC = \angle \Omega CA = \omega. $$

  2. Cyclically reversing orientation, the three circles tangent at $A, B, C$ in the opposite sense concur at the Second Brocard Point Ω′ (isogonal conjugate of Ω) with the same common acute angle $\angle \Omega' BA = \angle \Omega' CB = \angle \Omega' AC = \omega$.

  3. The Brocard Angle $\omega$ satisfies the fundamental cotangent and cosecant identities:

    $$ \cot \omega = \cot A + \cot B + \cot C = \frac{a^2 + b^2 + c^2}{4\Delta}, \qquad \csc^2 \omega = \csc^2 A + \csc^2 B + \csc^2 C, $$

    with sharp upper bound $\omega \le 30^\circ$ (equality iff $\triangle ABC$ is equilateral).

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. II, V & VII — Brocard Points Ω, Ω′, Brocard Circle, Steiner X(99) & Tarry X(98) ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml O ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 397657/891136 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ O K ]: 327*x/2360 - 392*y/295 + 10647/2360 = 0 [ B Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 - 915516*y/115249 + 5564832/115249 = 0 [ C Om1 ]: 985500*x/115249 + 121725*y/115249 - 6388200/115249 = 0 [ A Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 + 697970*y/115249 = 0 [ C Om2 ]: 853788*x/115249 + 107991*y/115249 - 5564832/115249 = 0 [ A Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 + 684236*y/115249 = 0 [ B Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 - 929250*y/115249 + 7408800/115249 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) Om1 = (697970/115249, 397488/115249) Om2 = (684236/115249, 529200/115249) A1 = (3589/590, 1014/295) B1 = (3491/590, 270/59) C1 = (7, 1176/295) St = (17253/2353, -9396/2353) Tr = (15689/2353, 115233/9412) A B C O K ML Ω Ω′ A1 B1 C1 St Tr

Supplementary Chapter, Section II Summary — Brocard Circle & Associated Points

Section II completes the Supplementary Chapter by uniting spiral similarity, isogonal bicentric pairs, and circumcircle concurrencies:

Casey Supp. Ch. Secs. II, V & VII — Brocard Points Ω, Ω′, Brocard Circle, Steiner X(99) & Tarry X(98) ( O A ): (x - 7)**2 + (y - 33/8)**2 - 4225/64 = 0 ( Ml O ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 397657/891136 = 0 ( Ml D1 ): (x - 1869/295)**2 + (y - 19143/4720)**2 - 19477081/891136 = 0 [ B C ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ C A ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ A B ]: y = 0 [ O K ]: 327*x/2360 - 392*y/295 + 10647/2360 = 0 [ B Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 - 915516*y/115249 + 5564832/115249 = 0 [ C Om1 ]: 985500*x/115249 + 121725*y/115249 - 6388200/115249 = 0 [ A Om1 ]: -397488*x/115249 + 697970*y/115249 = 0 [ C Om2 ]: 853788*x/115249 + 107991*y/115249 - 5564832/115249 = 0 [ A Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 + 684236*y/115249 = 0 [ B Om2 ]: -529200*x/115249 - 929250*y/115249 + 7408800/115249 = 0 A = (0, 0) B = (14, 0) C = (5, 12) O = (7, 33/8) K = (1673/295, 1176/295) Ml = (1869/295, 19143/4720) Om1 = (697970/115249, 397488/115249) Om2 = (684236/115249, 529200/115249) A1 = (3589/590, 1014/295) B1 = (3491/590, 270/59) C1 = (7, 1176/295) St = (17253/2353, -9396/2353) Tr = (15689/2353, 115233/9412) A B C O K ML Ω Ω′ A1 B1 C1 St Tr

Supplementary Chapter, Section II Notes — Brocard, Neuberg, Casey & ETC

In the Preface to the Fifth Edition (f. 0008, p. vi), John Casey explicitly acknowledges his personal correspondence with Joseph Neuberg (Liège), Henri Brocard (Montpellier/Algiers), Robert Tucker (London), and W. J. M'Clelland (Dublin). Notice two historical landmarks unique to this chapter: