Commentary on Proposition I.5: Untangling the Bridge of Asses via Symmetric Color Twins

Mirror-Symmetric Register Analysis & Rational Quadrances (I.5 · G.91)

Why I.5 Earned the Name Pons Asinorum—and How Byrne Tames It

In classical alphabetic editions, Proposition I.5 requires 329 words and 62 three-letter vertex-pointer dereferences because four overlapping triangles (AFC, AGB, BFC, CGB) share vertices A, B, C, F, G. On Pickering p. 5 (Leaf 39), Byrne assigns bilateral mirror twins (, , , , ), compressing the proof to 32 words (90.3% compression) and zero pointer lookups.

Exact Symbolic Model in geometor.byrne

In geometor.byrne.constructions.build_i5(), the isosceles triangle and its auxiliary extensions are constructed over exact rational coordinates $\mathbb{Q}$, verifying $Q(A,B)=Q(A,C)$, $Q(F,C)=Q(G,B)$, and exact equality of base spreads $s(BA, BC) = s(CA, CB)$ as well as exterior spreads $s(BF, BC) = s(CG, CB)$. (Compare Pappus's self-congruence shortcut in Proclus, geometor/proclus.)