Critique of Euclid, Superposition, and Rigid Bodies

Metrical Geometry (§§ 388–391, pp. 404–407)

§ 388. Metrical geometry presupposes projective or descriptive geometry

f. §388 · p. p. 404

388. The subject of the present chapter is elementary Geometry, as treated by Euclid or by any other author prior to the nineteenth century. This subject includes the usual analytical Geometry, whether Euclidean or non-Euclidean; it is distinguished from projective and descriptive Geometry, not by any opposition corresponding to that of Euclid and non-Euclid, but by its method and its indefinables. The question whether its indefinables can, or cannot, be defined in terms of those of projective and descriptive Geometry, is a very difficult one, which I postpone to the following chapter. For the present, I shall develop the subject straightforwardly, in a manner as similar to Euclid’s as is consistent with the requisite generality and with the avoidance of fallacies. Metrical Geometry is logically subsequent to the two kinds which we have examined, for it necessarily assumes one or other of these two kinds, to which it merely adds further specifications. I shall, as a rule, assume descriptive Geometry, mentioning projective Geometry only in connection with points in which it shows important metrical differences from descriptive Geometry. In the former case, all the first twenty-six propositions of Euclid will hold. In the latter, the first, seventh, sixteenth, and seventeenth require modification; for these propositions assume, in one form or another, that the straight line is not a closed series. Propositions after the twenty-sixth—or, with a suitable definition of parallels, after the twenty-eighth—depend, with few exceptions, upon the postulate of parallels, and are therefore not to be assumed generally.

§ 389. Errors in Euclid

f. §389 · p. p. 404

389. Since Euclid still has popularly, and even with mathematicians, a reputation for rigour, in virtue of which his circumlocution and long-windedness are condoned, it may be worth while to point out, to begin with, a few of the errors in his first twenty-six propositions [1]. To begin with the first proposition. There is no evidence whatever that the circles which we are told to construct intersect, and if they do not, the whole proposition fails. Euclid’s problems are often regarded as existence-theorems, and from this point of view, it is plain, the assumption that the circles in question intersect is precisely the same as the assumption that there is an equilateral triangle on a given base. And in elliptic space, where the straight line is a closed series, the construction fails when the length of the base exceeds half the length of the whole straight line. As regards the second and third propositions, there is nothing to be said, except that they are not existence-theorems. The corresponding existence-theorem—i.e. on any straight line, in either direction from a given point on the line, there is a point whose distance from the given point is equal to a given distance—is equivalent to the postulate concerning the circle, and is thus prior to the second and third propositions. With regard to the fourth, there is a great deal to be said; indeed Euclid’s proof is so bad that he would have done better to assume this proposition as an axiom [2]. As the issues raised by this proof are of great importance, both to mathematics and to philosophy, I shall set forth its fallacies at some length.

§ 390. Superposition is not a valid method

f. §390 · p. p. 405

390. The fourth proposition is the first in which Euclid employs the method of superposition—a method which, since he will make any détour to avoid it [3], he evidently dislikes, and rightly, since it has no logical validity, and strikes every intelligent child as a juggle. In the first place, to speak of motion implies that our triangles are not spatial, but material. For a point of space is a position, and can no more change its position than the leopard can change his spots. The motion of a point of space is a phantom directly contradictory to the law of identity: it is the supposition that a given point can be now one point and now another. Hence motion, in the ordinary sense, is only possible to matter, not to space. But in this case superposition proves no geometrical property. Suppose that the triangle ABC is by the window, and the side AB consists of the column of mercury in a thermometer; suppose also that DEF is by the fire. Let us apply ABC to DEF as Euclid directs, and let AB just cover DE. Then we are to conclude that ABC and DEF, before the motion, were equal in all respects. But if we had brought DEF to ABC, no such result would have followed. But how foolish! I shall be told; of course ABC and DEF are to be both rigid bodies. Well and good. But two little difficulties remain. In the first place—and for my opponent, who is an empirical philosopher, this point is serious—it is as certain as anything can be that there are no rigid bodies in the universe. In the second place—and if my opponent were not an empiricist, he would find this objection far more fatal—the meaning of rigidity presupposes a purely spatial metrical equality, logically independent of matter. For what is meant by a rigid body? It is one which, throughout a continuous portion of time, preserves all its metrical properties unchanged. Hence we incur a most fatally vicious circle if we attempt to define metrical properties by rigidity. If αβγ be a material triangle, which occupies at one time the space ABC, at another the space $A'B'C'$, to say that αβγ is rigid means that, however the two times be chosen (within some assigned period), the triangles ABC, $A'B'C'$ are equal in all respects. If we are to avoid this conclusion, we must define rigidity in some wholly non-geometrical manner. We may say, for example, that a rigid body means one which is made of steel, or of brass. But then it becomes a logical error to regard brass eternal as slave to mortal rage; and if we define equal spaces as those which can be occupied by one and the same rigid body, the propositions of metrical Geometry will be one and all false.

The fact is that motion, as the word is used by geometers, has a meaning entirely different from that which it has in daily life, just as a variable, in mathematics, is not something which changes, but is usually, on the contrary, something incapable of change. So it is with motion. Motion is a certain class of one-one relations, each of which has every point of space for its extension, and each of which has a converse also belonging to the class. That is, a motion is a one-one relation, in which the referent and the relatum are both points, and in which every point may appear as referent and again as relatum. A motion is not this only: on the contrary, it has this further characteristic, that the metrical properties of any class of referents are identical with those of the corresponding class of relata. This characteristic, together with the other, defines a motion as used in Geometry, or rather, it defines a motion or a reflexion; but this point need not be elucidated at present. What is clear is, that a motion presupposes the existence, in different parts of space, of figures having the same metrical properties, and cannot be used to define those properties. And it is this sense of the word motion, not the usual material sense, which is relevant to Euclid’s use of superposition.

§ 391. Errors in Euclid (continued)

f. §391 · p. p. 406

391. Returning now to Euclid’s fourth proposition, we see that the superposition of ABC on DEF involves the following assumptions. (1) On the line DE there is a point E, on either side of D, such that DE = AB. This is provided for by the postulate about the circle. (2) On either side of the ray DE, there is a ray DF such that the angle EDF is equal to the angle BAC. This is required for the possibility of a triangle DEF such as the enunciation demands, but no axiom from which this follows can be found in Euclid. The problem, to construct an angle EDF equal to BAC, does not occur till I. 23, and there I. 4 is used in the proof. Hence the present assumption must be added to Euclid’s axioms. It now follows that on DF there is a point F such that DF = AC. Hence the possibility of two such triangles as the enunciation demands is established. But in order to prove that DEF is equal in all respects to ABC, we need a further axiom, namely: With one angle at D, one side along the ray DE, and the other side to the right (or left) of DE, there exists a triangle which is equal in all respects to the triangle ABC [4]. This is, in fact, the exact assumption which is concealed in the method of superposition. With this assumption, it finally becomes possible to prove that DEF is the triangle satisfying the above conditions and equal in all respects to ABC.

The next remark concerns I. 6. Here Euclid first employs an axiom of which he is wholly unconscious, though it is very essential to his system, namely: If OA, OB, OC be three rays which meet a straight line not passing through O in A, B, C respectively, and if B be between A and C, then the angle AOB is less than the angle AOC. This axiom, it will be seen, is not applicable in projective space, since it presupposes that the line is not a closed series. In I. 7, if this proposition is to apply to hyperbolic space, we require further the axiom: If three non-intersecting lines in one plane meet two lines in A, B, C; $A'$, $B'$, $C'$, respectively; and if B be between A and C; then $B'$ is between $A'$ and $C'$. Also it may be observed that Euclid gives no definition of the two sides of a line, a notion which again presupposes that the straight line is not a closed series. And with regard to angles, I. 7 requires sufficient axioms to show that they are a series of the kind explained in Part IV, Chapter xxiv; or else we must assume the descriptive axiom of the last chapter, to the effect that, if A, B, C, D be coplanar points, no three of which are collinear, there is a point common to the stretches AB, CD, or to AC, BD, or to AD, BC. All these assumptions will be found implicit in I. 7, as may be seen by attempting a symbolic proof in which no figure is used.

Similar remarks apply to I. 16. In I. 12 it is assumed that a circle must meet a line in two points, if at all. But enough has been said to show that Euclid is not faultless, and that his explicit axioms are very insufficient. Let us, then, make an independent examination of metrical Geometry.

Footnotes