Chapter I: Definition of Pure Mathematics¶
Part I — The Indefinables of Mathematics (§§ 1–10, pp. 3–9)
Chapter I (Definition of Pure Mathematics, §§1–10, pp. 3–9) opens The Principles of Mathematics with arguably the most famous sentence in twentieth-century philosophy of mathematics, defining pure mathematics as the class of all formal implications p implies q containing only unrestricted variables and logical constants. Geometry is thereby split cleanly into two distinct enterprises: pure geometry, which proves strictly logical implications of the form ‘if $S$ is a Euclidean (or hyperbolic) space, then $S$ possesses property $P$’, and applied geometry, an empirical branch of physics asking whether actual perceptual space instantiates $S$.
Pure Mathematics as Formal Implication (p implies q)
1. Pure Mathematics is the class of all propositions of the form “p implies q,” where p and q are propositions containing one or more variables, the same in the two propositions, and neither p nor q contains any constants except logical constants. And logical constants are all notions definable in terms of the following: Implication, the relation of a term to a class of which it is a member, the notion of such that, the notion of relation, and such further notions as may be involved in the general notion of propositions of the above form. In addition to these, mathematics uses a notion which is not a constituent of the propositions which it considers, namely the notion of truth.
Logical Constants, Variables, and Relation to Pure Logic
6. Mathematical propositions are not only characterized by the fact that they assert implications, but also by the fact that they contain variables. The notion of the variable is one of the most difficult with which Logic has to deal, and in the present work a satisfactory theory as to its nature, in spite of much discussion, will hardly be found. For the present, I only wish to make it plain that there are variables in all mathematical propositions, even where at first sight they might seem to be absent. Elementary Arithmetic might be thought to form an exception: 1 + 1 = 2 appears neither to contain variables nor to assert an implication. But as a matter of fact, as will be shown in Part II, the true meaning of this proposition is: “If x is one and y is one, and x differs from y, then x and y are two.” And this proposition both contains variables and asserts an implication. We shall find always, in all mathematical propositions, that the words any or some occur; and these words are the marks of a variable and a formal implication. Thus the above proposition may be expressed in the form: “Any unit and any other unit are two units.” The typical proposition of mathematics is of the form “φ(x, y, z, …) implies ψ(x, y, z, …), whatever values x, y, z, … may have”; where φ(x, y, z, …) and ψ(x, y, z, …), for every set of values of x, y, z, …, are propositions. It is not asserted that φ is always true, nor yet that ψ is always true, but merely that, in all cases, when φ is false as much as when φ is true, ψ follows from it.