Part II: Pure Geometric Exhaustion (Propositions 18–24)¶
To demonstrate the theorem purely geometrically without mechanical postulates, Archimedes defines the base AC, vertex B (point of maximum perpendicular height, where the tangent is parallel to AC), and height of any segment:
Propositions 18–19: If diameters through the midpoints F, G of AD (half-chord) meet the parabola at secondary vertices D, E, then (actually measured from the chord, so the sub-segment height is of the main height measured along the diameter!).
Proposition 20: If ABC be a parabolic segment with vertex B, then triangleABC is greater than half the area of the segment ABC (since triangleABC is half of the circumscribed parallelogram formed by the tangent at B and diameters through A, C). Repeated inscription therefore exhausts the segment by Eucl. X. 1!
Proposition 21: If D, E be the vertices of the two remaining segments on AB and BC, then:
\[\triangle ABC = 8 \cdot \triangle ADB = 8 \cdot \triangle BEC, \qquad \text{whence} \qquad \triangle ADB + \triangle BEC = \frac{1}{4} \triangle ABC.\]Proposition 22: For any finite sequence of areas ABCDdots formed at successive stages of this bisection, their sum is strictly less than the area of the parabolic segment.
Proposition 23 (Exact Finite Geometric Series Identity):
Given a series of areas ABCDdotsZ, of which A is the greatest, and each is equal to four times the next in order, then:
\[A + B + C + D + \dots + Z + \frac{1}{3} Z = \frac{4}{3} A.\]Proof: Add , , …, . Since , , …, , summing all terms gives . Subtracting from both sides leaves !
Proposition 24 (Geometric Quadrature of the Parabola):
Every segment bounded by a parabola and a chord AC is equal to four-thirds of the triangle ABC which has the same base as the segment and equal height.Let .
Suppose the segment greater than K: Inscribe triangles recursively until the remaining parabolic segments leave a sum less than (Prop. 20, Eucl. X. 1). Then the inscribed polygon , contradicting Prop. 23 ()!
Suppose the segment less than K: Let , , …, continuing until the last term Z is less than . By Prop. 23, , whence , contradicting Prop. 22!
Therefore the parabolic segment is neither greater nor less than ; it is strictly equal to .