Proposition 3: Circumference-to-Diameter Bounds (3 10/71 < π < 3 1/7)

The ratio of the circumference of any circle to its diameter is less than but greater than .

I. Proof of the Upper Bound ()

f. Heath (1897), pp. 93–96 · Heiberg I, 262–267 · p. 94

Let AB be the diameter of any circle, O its centre, AC the tangent at A; and let the angle AOC be one-third of a right angle (). Then:

  • , and .

  1. First Bisection (12-gon): Draw OD bisecting angleAOC. By the angle-bisector theorem (Eucl. VI. 3), , so , or . Hence:

    \[OA : AD > 571 : 153, \qquad OD^2 : AD^2 > (571^2 + 153^2) : 153^2 = 349450 : 23409,\]

    whence (Eucl. I. 47) .

  2. Second Bisection (24-gon): Let OE bisect angleAOD. By the same composition of ratios:

    \[OA : AE > 1162\frac{1}{8} : 153, \qquad OE : EA > 1172\frac{1}{8} : 153.\]
  3. Third Bisection (48-gon): Let OF bisect angleAOE. Then:

    \[OA : AF > 2334\frac{1}{4} : 153, \qquad OF : FA > 2339\frac{1}{4} : 153.\]
  4. Fourth Bisection (96-gon): Let OG bisect angleAOF. Then:

    \[OA : AG > 4673\frac{1}{2} : 153.\]

Since angleAOC, which is one-third of a right angle, has been bisected four times, angleAOG is of a right angle. Make angleAOHangleAOG on the opposite side of OA; then angleGOH is of a right angle, so GH is one side of a regular polygon of 96 sides circumscribed to the circle. Since and , the ratio of the diameter to the perimeter of the circumscribed 96-gon satisfies:

\[AB : P_{96}^{\text{circ}} > 4673\frac{1}{2} : (96 \times 153) = 4673\frac{1}{2} : 14688.\]

Now . A fortiori, the circumference of the circle—being strictly less than —is less than times the diameter.

II. Proof of the Lower Bound ()

f. Heath (1897), pp. 96–98 · Heiberg I, 266–271 · p. 96

Next let AB be the diameter of a circle, and let AC, meeting the circle in C, make the angle CAB equal to one-third of a right angle (). Join BC; then angleACB in the semicircle is right (Eucl. III. 31), and:

  • , while .

  1. First Bisection (12-gon): Let AD bisect angleCAB, meeting BC in d and the circle in D. Join BD. By similar right triangles triangleADBsimtriangleACdsimtriangleBdD (Eucl. III. 21, Eucl. VI. 3):

    \[AD : DB = (AB + AC) : BC < 2911 : 780, \qquad AB : BD < 3013\frac{3}{4} : 780.\]
  2. Second Bisection (24-gon): Let AE bisect angleDAB, meeting the circle in E. Reducing by the factor after composition:

    \[AE : EB < 5924\frac{3}{4} : 780 = 1823 : 240, \qquad AB : BE < 1838\frac{9}{11} : 240.\]
  3. Third Bisection (48-gon): Let AF bisect angleEAB, meeting the circle in F. Reducing by the factor :

    \[AF : FB < 3661\frac{9}{11} : 240 = 1007 : 66, \qquad AB : BF < 1009\frac{1}{6} : 66.\]
  4. Fourth Bisection (96-gon): Let AG bisect angleFAB, meeting the circle in G. Then:

    \[AG : GB < 2016\frac{1}{6} : 66, \qquad AB : BG < 2017\frac{1}{4} : 66.\]

Inverting, the side BG of the inscribed regular 96-gon bears to the diameter AB a ratio greater than . Hence the perimeter of the inscribed 96-gon satisfies:

\[P_{96}^{\text{insc}} : AB > (96 \times 66) : 2017\frac{1}{4} = 6336 : 2017\frac{1}{4} = 3 + \frac{284\frac{1}{4}}{2017\frac{1}{4}} > 3\frac{10}{71},\]

since . A fortiori, the circumference of the circle—being strictly greater than —is greater than times the diameter.

Thus the ratio of the circumference to the diameter is less than and greater than .