2. Determination of the Evolute Diorismos [Props. 99–100 / V. 51–52]¶
Apollonius next poses the profound diorismos problem for an arbitrary point O off the axis: how many normals can be drawn through O that cut the axis between O and the vertex?
Plate 9 — Normals & the Astroidal Evolute Envelope (Book V.51–63 [Props. 99–106]). Inside the four-cusped evolute , an interior point O admits four distinct normals OP1OP2OP3OP4 to the ellipse; on the evolute two normals coalesce at a center of curvature; outside the evolute only two real normals exist.
Proposition 99 [V. 51, 52] — Exact Evolute Threshold. If AM measured along the axis from vertex A be greater than (and in the ellipse less than AC), and if MO be drawn perpendicular to the axis, then a critical length can be assigned by pure cubic/mean-proportional division along the axis such that:
(a) if , no normal can be drawn through O cutting the axis in that quadrant (only 2 normals exist globally on an ellipse);
(b) if , one unique coalesced normal can be so drawn through O (hence O lies directly on the evolute!);
(c) if , two distinct normals can be so drawn in that quadrant (yielding 4 real normals globally on an ellipse, or 3 on the evolute!).