Summary: The Minimal-Instrument Regimes & Algebraic Constructibility

Comparative Architecture of Ruler+Compass, Mascheroni Compass-Only, and Poncelet–Steiner Fixed-Circle

1. Instrument Regimes & Operation Subspaces

Constructibility & Operation Subspaces Across Classical and Minimal Instruments

Regime

Primary Literature

Operation Symbol

Algebraic Field & Invariance

Canonical Ruler + Compass

Euclid (euclid-elements), Lemoine (lemoine-1902)

\(l_1 R_1 + l_2 R_2 + m_1 C_1 + m_2 C_2 + m_3 C_3\)

Full Euclidean quadratic closure \(\mathbb{E}\) (nested square roots \(\sqrt{x^2 \pm y^2}\))

Mascheroni Compass Alone

Mohr (mohr-1672), Mascheroni (mascheroni-1797)

\(m_1 C_1 + m_2 C_2 + m_3 C_3\) (\(l_1 = l_2 = 0\))

Full Euclidean quadratic closure \(\mathbb{E}\) (straight lines implicit as point-pairs \((A, B)\))

Poncelet–Steiner Straightedge + Fixed Circle :math:`M`

Poncelet (poncelet-1822), Steiner (steiner-1833)

\(l_1 R_1 + l_2 R_2\) (\(m_1 = m_2 = m_3 = 0\))

Full Euclidean quadratic closure \(\mathbb{E}\) (circles implicit as center \(M_1\) + radius endpoint)

Hilbert Straightedge + Eichmaß (Unit Gauge)

Hilbert (hilbert-1899, §§ 36–39)

\(R_1, R_2\) + movable unit-segment transferrer

Strictly Pythagorean subfield \(\Omega_{\text{pyth}}\) (\(\sqrt{1 + \omega^2}\), strictly smaller than \(\mathbb{E}\))

2. The Eight Fundamental Problems (Drittes Kapitel, § 18)

Steiner’s Eight Fundamental Tasks

Task

Problem Statement

Primary Apparatus

Operation Count

Erste

Parallel through a point to a given line ([68]–[71])

Complete quadrangle on diameter \(ab\)

\(11R_1 + 6R_2, S = 17\)

Zweite

Segment multiplication and rational division ([71])

Parallel lines + harmonic diagonals

Pure linear scaling

Dritte

Perpendicular to a given line through a point ([71]–[75])

Thales chord / orthocenter on diameter

\(10R_1 + 5R_2, S = 15\)

Vierte

Angle copy to a given vertex and ray ([75])

Parallel chords in fixed circle \(\Omega\)

Pure straightedge transport

Fünfte

Angle bisection and multiplication ([75]–[76])

Subtended chord parallel in \(\Omega\)

Straightedge bisection

Sechste

Segment transfer from a point along a ray ([76]–[78])

Centers of similitude A, I

Homothetic ray projection

Siebente

Line intersection with virtual circle \((M_1, r_1)\) ([78]–[82])

Homothetic projection to drawn circle \(\Omega\)

Line–line transfer

Achte

Intersection of two virtual circles ([82]–[85])

Radical axis reduced to Task 7

Complete Euclidean reduction